Reviews for Pizza Cottage in Grove City, OH
Some of the best pizza and subs around! Service was very inviting and I think I found my new go to for P. L. T\'s ( just like a... blt but with pepperoni) don\'t miss out! Read more
The food is good and the service fine but almost forty dollars for a small pizza, sub, 5 wings, and three bread sticks is a... little pricey. Read more
I ordered takeout from Pizza Cottage shortly after it opened. It was very busy and the parking lot was full. When going in for... takeout make sure you go to the hostess stand not the bar. There is also a drive thru window. I picked up a pepperoni pizza withextra cheese and an order of spaghetti with meat sauce and one with signature sauce. The pizza was good, not great. It has thatthick crust that most places have. I prefer a thin or a true pan crust. But I liked the spaghetti and wanted to try it again.Today I chose a side order of fettuccine, a side order of ravioli, two spaghetti dinners with extra meat sauce, and an order ofgarlic bread with cheese. The side order and the dinner entree are the same size, the difference is the dinners include a sidesalad and garlic bread. You can upgrade the bread and add ingredients to the salad at an additional cost. The meat sauceincludes lots of chunks of meat with tomatoes and onions. I ordered extra sauce but there wasn\'t enough for my taste. Thesauce makes the dish. The Alfredo sauce was good but I wished I had more of that also. The star was the ravioli. Lots ofcheese filling and there was enough sauce without requesting extra. It tasted fresh, the pasta was perfect. The garlic breadwas a bottom sub bun with garlic butter that was more like toast. Strangely, the garlic bread with cheese made the same way wasdelicious, maybe because it was the top bun. Neither was over seasoned with garlic. They weren\'t as busy as they were on myfirst visit. Staff was friendly both times. My order was ready when promised. Overall this is a great place for a good meal,not too expensive and very filling. Four stars only because I didn\'t love the pizza and it\'s in their name. Read more
So yummy! We enjoyed a pizza, a chicken salad and some bredsticks. First off, the breadsticks are fantastic. Not crazy... buttery, but just enough flavor. The large salad is in fact that, large. It was very good. But their pizza is what we wentfor, and boy was it good. The crust is light and crispy, without being dry and \"crackery.\" The toppings all were fresh andflavorful. Great find, I will be back the next time I am in the Columbus area. Read more
The signature pasta sauce is delicious and portions are generous. I could eat the past sauce like soup!! The pizza is really... great too. Again, there is generosity in pizza toppings, as well! My teenage sons very much enjoy the Fettuccine Alfredo withchicken. We\'ve been known to order delivery twice in one week! Read more
Sensational pizza pie! First time visitor and they were gracious to grant my request of standard-- or triangle cut crust.... Generous toppings and rich sauce. The staff is warm and quick with a smile. 7.8 ???? Read more
Opening night! We got seated pretty quickly for a packed restaurant on day 1! Our pizza was excellent! Alley gave us great... service and the remodel is beautiful! Great opening night! Read more
Clean and cozy and great service. Very nice space with roomy booths.. Lots of TVs for game watching too. Got Ruthie\'s Way steak... sub. ???? wow. Fantastic flavor and enough for 2 people (IMO) But I guess a guy could eat the whole thing!\nDefinitely recommendand will be back. Came in with a large group at a moment\'s notice and it was no problem at all. Read more