Reviews for Gabby's Pizza in Hackettstown, NJ
While paying I noticed the cash register and credit card machines filthy. I feared if that reflected the kitchen. That was my... first time there and those machines didn't make a good impression. I recommend cleaning them. Read more
Local family owned, these are people in our community. We know their names and they know ours. We got pizza to go. Very nice and... delicious. Try the Tres Leches. Definitely recommend. Read more
Ordered pizza for the first time from here. Food was delivered hot, plain pizza was good. The Buffalo chicken pizza comes with... red sauce on it. It is not listed anywhere on their online menu that it does. So for those people who don't like red sauce andlove Buffalo chicken pizza make sure to ask for it without red sauce. I did not think I would have to because I have neverordered a Buffalo chicken pizza that has also come with red sauce on it. Read more
used to love this place but it has consistently gone down hill. today i got a prosciutto sandwich & the prosciutto was spoiled.... i ordered right before closing so i couldn?t call to resolve the issue but it was very disappointing to say the least. would askfor a refund but from other reviewers i doubt they will give it to me. unfortunate because i loved this place. Read more
Pizza was delivered cold, under cooked and looking like this. I asked for a refund but the nephew said he did not know what to... do and would have the owner call me. Waited over an hour for phone call back. My 3 yr old son, mother and myself were starvingso we ate the pizza Owner called me and said he would refund my money unless I gave him the pizza back. I told him we werehungry waited an hour so we heated it up and ate. Owner refused to refund my money back because he didn't believe. This is thefirst time we ever had this issue. Very sad to see.. Read more
To start, we called to ensure that the hours were correct. To say that their phone etiquette was not good is understated. But... that did not deter the Pizza Hunters App while looking for the Best Slice of Pizza. First impressions that the place did notlook clean. The glass had hand prints everywhere. The 12 tables in the place had large numbers above each table which reallylessened the look. The garbage can had 3 whole pizzas in it from pies that were clearly over cooked. We finally placed our orderand the man behind the counter was not friendly. The phone rings and we got to listen to an apparent customer who was not happyabout their order, and we didn't even get our slices yet. The experience matched the pizza slice. Not very good. Basically nosauce on the slice with no form to the crust which was doey and wet. Another pizza parlor that just takes your money with nocommunication. Did you enjoy your pizza? Have you been here before? Hello, Thank You and come again are all suggested ways topotentially communicate with your customers. This may be a a good slice of pizza to service the local community , but this isnot even on the radar in 2019 for the Best NJ Slice. Read more
Good pizza if you tell them that you want it really thin and light on the sauce. If there were half stars this place would get 3... 1/5 stars. Read more
Good pizza. Could use a little more sauce but overall one of the better places in town.