Reviews for Paul & Eddy's Pizza in Hamden, CT
I ordered a Sub with salami, american cheese, ham and lettuce, and tomatoes. The sandwich was made well and everything was... fresh. The time I will order a pizza. Read more
Horrible customer service- you call they just put the phone down for 20 mins- call back and it’s the same thing. I order the... same thing and depending on who’s working there it’s different prices- and the delivery driver shorted me When delivering myfood. NOT TO MENTION THE PIECE OF PLASTIC AND HAIR FOUND IN OUR FOOD- we will NEVER ORDER FROM THERE AGain!! Read more
The driver didn’t give me the right change he shorted me $10.00 then when I call and speak to the owner he says oh well he... don’t remember so the next time you order you can take 5 dollars off- I was confused- I asked for my money back and he hadsuch a nasty attitude and told me if I can catch him in the morning he would give me my ten dollars back! I had work so Icouldn’t go but I went after work and they said they told me to come in the am and obviously I was lying! ???? so rude andhurtful Read more
Such a friendly and nice place to grab a pizza or some calzones. Their crust is delicious, salty and crunchy but not burnt. I do... like some char don't get me wrong but Paul and Eddy's is making a seriously tasty dough over there char or not. My kids like thepizza a lot but the calzones are where it's at for me. Read more
So today March 28th 2022 I ordered pizza from paul and Eddie’s because we got a flyer in the mail saying they were... celebrating thirty years, we waited 45 minutes for a large Hawaiian pizza and the first time it was burnt and so hard you couldgo knocking on doors with it the when we called and asked if the pizza was meant to be like that they said no and theyapologized and said they were going to send a new one we waited another 20 minutes and it was worse than the first one and thenwhen we called again to ask if they were playing a joke or something they said the first one was not burnt and so the second onewasn’t either, this was so frustrating and annoying and the level of ignorance they had was insane I can’t believe they’vebeen in business for 30 years with that customer service and that food never ordering again. Photos of first and second pizzaattached Read more
$2.50 for HALF meatball.... $2.50 for HALF bacon, which was on 2 slices, (same price as full pie). $2.50 extra cheese? If that's... extra cheese..... I'm glad I ordered extra cheese! The tomato was the only thing worth the topping price and even $2.50 for itwas steep! Burned and not even cooked underneath. Very disappointed ???? I had it years ago and was excited to go here again.Very disappointed. Read more
Sad to say the quality’s been going downhill lately. I thought the first dud was a fluke but tonight’s pizza came burnt,... thin, and the cheese was non-existent. It’s a shame because they used to be our go-to for take out pizza. Read more
So...this has to be THE WORST experience we've EVER had at P&E's. There have been as many BAD as there was GOOD..... My husband... has been going there for years, and knows the owner pretty well. They used to be Hamdens best kept secret. Now...you don't knowif your going to get a decent pie, or a half cooked pile of dough and cheese. We have ordered here before and it was delicious. Very disappointed. The mozzarella tasted like it sat out all day. It tasted awful.We ordered a tomatoes basil mozzarella andricotta pie. Numerous times we have ordered that same pizza and it was delicious, this time it was awful.. It was like a childmade it. I don't think I'll be calling here again. Unfortunate because we really liked this place Read more