Reviews for Oliveri's Pizzeria in Hamilton, NY
I am visiting for business and was looking for a place to deliver. The hotel I'm staying in suggested this place. I ordered... their Margherita pizza and it taste great and they were punctual about their delivery. I however can't give a full 5 star ratingbecause of two reasons. The pizza wasn't really cut into slices like it should have been and they way over did the tomatoes.Cherry tomatoes are fine but I feel thin slices of Roma tomatoes would of been better. Having been a chef for 9 years as well asranked as a top 10% local guide in the states I hope they read this and can adjust things so the next person doesn't have thesame issues. Read more
Very rude service! I?m a professor at Colgate new to the area. I called to place an order for delivery at this restaurant.... Exactly one hour after placing my order (and still waiting for the food) I got a call where a man very rudely asked for adifferent card number. I?ve rarely been spoken to in such a tone at a restaurant before. It saddens me that with the limitedchoices for delivery in the area, they can get away with treating people any way they please. Read more
They currently only offer take out during dinner and are closed Wednesday nights. Just be patient (they're clearly very popular)... and it is worth the wait. The calzones are huge and delicious! Read more
Oliveri?s has good?and pretty close to authentic?. Italian food, BUT the owner Mike could really use a good lesson in business... etiquette. Instead of being a man of his word (he offered to fix HIS mistake by refunding our $100+ order), he lied through histeeth and then ignored the situation in its entirety. A restaurant with the best food is only as good as it?s ownership. Dobetter Mike! Read more
Visiting for a wedding from Colorado. Born in Binghamton but moved in the early 60s. A slice from Oliveri's was the best I have... had in all that time. SO GOOD! NY pizza rules but Oliveri's has got my vote for the best! Do they deliver to Boulder? Read more
We went to Oliveris for lunch yesterday and I have to be honest this is the best pizza I have ever had. We ordered the stuffed... lasagna pizza! It was cooked perfectly and the ingredients were delicious. They even had bottles of mikes hot honey for salewhich was delicious on the pizza! Top notch, highly recommend! Read more
I'm in town for a month from FL and was looking forward to an authentic NY style pizza durring my stay. After two weeks of... searching, we found Oliveri's and to my surprise, Stuffed Lasagna Pizza, my absolute favorite pizza, was on the menu! This pizzais by far the best pizza I've ever had! The sauce to cheese ratio is perfect, the crust is nice and crispy and there is awonderful surprise in the rolled crust, a soft doughy center like a hidden breadstick! Between 3 of us, only a 1/4 of this piesurvived! The wings here are also to die for, they're fried nice and crispy, and coated evenly is a great sauce! I encourageeveryone to try their Itallian Wedding soup, it is delicious, home made, all from scratch and will warm you up on these chillyfall/winter days! Oh, and before I forget the customer service and staff are amazing! Everyone is very friendly, they're fast,and willing to help with whatever you need! All around a great experience, not once but twice! Read more
Quick service Ordered spaghetti with meatballs. The sauce was very good Also a eggplant panini. I can see a return in the... future. Sorry no pictures Read more