Reviews for Costello's Pizzeria & Wings in Hammonton, NJ

Ordered Buffalo ears, cheese fries, and a roast beef sub. Ears were good with a nice amount of blue cheese (no skimping there) ... fries were good, kinda disappointed in the sub. Roast beef sub was very skinny, maybe 1/4 inch of meat on it and I can't makemention of the taste as it wasn't mine. Also when ordering online- they don't honor thier offer to bring curbside. I tipped20% because I thought they were bringing it out. Won't stop me from trying again, I'll just hope for more substance in a subnext time. Read more

Orderd LG Pizza extra cheese and sausage and 12 honey BBQ wings I ordered it and 18 minutes it was at my door no way did they... just make it it was a pizza sitting around a while I will never again order from them again Read more

My go to spot almost weekly - fast deliveries too ! Wings , pizza and hoagies let?s go! Josh

Great pizza in Hammonton! I had a couple of slices of pepperoni that were well done and crispy just how I like it. Sauce was... great, slightly spicy, not sweet like many pizzerias. Staff was friendly, restaurant is small inside but neat and very clean.Definitely give this place a try! Read more

So I ordered today, cheese pie with half extra cheese and Buffalo chicken pie. Waited over and hour because of what they said... was volume of orders. That was the problem the was problem it came with the temp just at warm and the cheese pie didn't haveextra cheese and it was over cooked and dry and the Buffalo pie didn't have any favor and was also dry. I have been away fromhome for a but month and finally back home to get some real pizza that you can't get while traveling and this is what I get.Highly disappointed and may never order from them again. Read more

Got the buffalo tails and they were delicious! Chicken was very moist!! Will definitely be back!

The crust is soft and delicious and the cheese was a bit thick. But there was not a lot of sauce and I am hoping next time that... you add more sauce and a little less cheese. The delivery guy was great and had a great attitude. Read more

We ordered from here for our family Christmas gathering for the first time. I can tell you we will be coming back. The food... was amazing and the prices were pretty good too. The sub tray was packed and the wings were the best we ever had. What I lovedwas they gave you forks, knives, onions, hot peppers, sweet peppers all on the side. For years I went to the local Italianmarkets for Christmas and was always disappointed, so glad we tried this place. Thanks again for great food. Read more