Loading

Reviews for The New York Restaurant in Harbor Springs, MI

joe vanhamlin 1 year ago
1

Service was terrible. 45 minute wait time for entrée. You don't get bread nor a salad with dinner unless you pay extra. Way... overpriced for what it was. Don't order the duck. Pretty sure it was just chicken. 0 stars. It wasn't even that busy. Will nevergo back. Read more

Ed Sands 1 year ago
5

Absolutely delicious dinner. Wine, appetizer, glorious Veal dish and apple pie a la mode. Excellent service. Will be back ????

Bree Kondrat 1 year ago
5

Charming spot for a night out. Service is excellent, friendly, warm and attentive. Order the halibut, or the ribeye, both are... fantastic. Wish I would have saved room for the homemade apple pie. I am partial to this place, it holds a lot of memories forus. My husband proposed here and it was the first place we took our son on his first "nice dinner out". I love it for datenights but it's a great place to meet friends. Read more

Nancy Faris 1 year ago
3

We look forward to the New York restaurant in Harbor Springs each summer. This year we were very disappointed. At 6pm they... were out of 2 of the dishes we wanted to order. The tomato buffalo mozarella salad had no dressing, wedge salad wasnt a wedgeand didnt match the description otherwise. My whitefish was delicious, but served with green beans on one side and a very drycombination of huge butter beans, kidney beans and garbanzos, unseasoned on the orher side. What was the chef thinking? Thetable had nice linens but completely empty except for flatware and bread plates, though no bread was served. Would have beennice in such an elegant setting to have at least a candle or some flowers. Our waitress was excellent and i felt sorry for her. We will be waiting a couple years before going back. Read more

Heather Wing 1 year ago
5

Elegant dining spot in a beautiful downtown Harbor Springs location. Very large wine selection for the sommelier in your group.... Reservations strongly encouraged, keep your beach wear at home and dress up a bit. Rotating seasonal menu. The fried chickendish with homemade egg noodles was fantastic, the roasted cauliflower Indian dish was so-so. An extra vegetarian option or twowould probably be appreciated. On a busy Friday night, our main courses took over an hour to prepare so be aware and order asalad or appetizer. Read more

Robert Young 4 years ago
5

We've been wanting to try this place for quite a while. They were open Sunday, and worth the wait. Wedge salad, filet mignon, ... apple dessert. Glass of wine. Perfect end of day stop near Petoskey. Read more

Jennifer Carlson 4 years ago
4

Outstanding salmon, good filet mignon - great, attentive service at the bar! Certain entrees are b1g1 between 5:00 and 5:30. ... Reservations are apparently required, though - we got the last two seats at the bar, while 3 tables sat empty the whole time wewere there. It got very loud and crowded at the bar toward end of our meal. Read more

Ray Terwilliger 5 years ago
5

Outstanding fine dinning experience tonight! Kari and the rest of the staff provided impeccable service. We will certainly... revisit next time we're in the area. The perfect place to celebrate my 3 year anniversary to the love of my life... Read more