Reviews for Black Eyed Susans Tavern & Restaurant in Harvey Cedars, NJ

We had our wedding reception here at Black Eyed Susans. We couldn't have picked a better place to have it at. The space was... gorgeous, food was amazing, the servers, bartenders, and the owner were all so great and accommodating. Highly recommend BlackEyed Susans! They are wonderful!! Read more

Great experience! Good energy, Great atmosphere and a fun crowd. And the owners were wonderful and fully engaged. The pizzas... are by far the best on this side of the island. The gazpacho just made you smile. Fun wine list as well - Read more

We have been going to this restaurant for many years and have loved it. We live on LBI and appreciate the local restaurants.... Tonight we had a reservation for two (It’s September) and our babysitter backed out. We called to add our child added to thereservation and were treated horribly. You would think that they would be understanding or at least nice. We were put on holdfor what I think was a manager and she was insulting! Her comment was that the tables were 24 inches!! My family and I have goneto this restaurant many, many times.. paid hundreds of dollars per meal, and the food is good. I have never been treated likethis as a customer in any restaurant I have been to. I WILL never eat there again! It is a shame because the chef is good. Butyou have to know what your staff is doing to your customers. So sad. Read more

This restaurant was exactly what our family was looking for on a great beach weekend. The apps were satisfactory ???????? The... mains were perfect with fresh flavors ???????? The Cocktail were delicious ???????? And to top off off a Perfect Saturday nightvibe ???????? What else can you ask for? Oh ya the extremely helpful and informative staff. I had a few food questions andthey advised me along the way! They also have a great space for large groups and events if needed. Check them out the nexttime you are close by! Read more

This absolutely one of the best restaurants on LBI!! You will not find a more friendly staff, service is incredible, food is... more than delicious. Whether you are having a simple pizza or one of the amazing fish dishes. Chef Chris has a way of bringingout all of the flavors. The black garlic cesar salad is a must start. I highly recommend this restaurant, we go at least once aweek. Read more

No doubt the best high end bar/restaurant in the Island. They go above and beyond in all the details. A short but sweet menú,... lovely wine picks, refreshing cocktails, every day specials, and of course, food for the people who enjoys well roundedmeals. Do not miss the olives, this is their diamond ???? Pizza had the best sauce flavor. The owners is a couple of Chef andfront of the house who takes care with love of all the customers ?? Do reserve in advance! Otherwise you will have to go earlyand try to find a spot in the bar. Read more

Wow! That was a great dinner. Went for a final family meal on the island, and found ourselves impressed. Between our party of 6... we tried a bit of everything, the Angry Crab pizza and Lobster gnocchi especially impressed. Read more

Wonderful food. It is incredibly fresh and scratch made. The lobster gnocchi and pizza are a must. Will definitely be going... back. Read more