Reviews for Frankies Pizza in Hayward, WI
We stopped in for a late supper on our way home. The pizza was delicious, the Alfredo was good too. Bloody Mary was very... delicious. And the bartender was great, loved that she wore gloves when touching any food. We will be back when in the areaagain. Read more
Stopped at Frankie's on our way through town last week. Only a few others in the place but it was Sunday afternoon. Pizza was... very good and service was attentive. However, I noticed some discrepancies in our bill. They charged us for a call drink whenwe never asked for anything but rail. Our friends asked to sub black olives for green and were charged extra for the blackolives. They also asked for tomatoes which they knew was an upcharge but there were no tomatoes on the pizza. All of thesesmall up-charges added a couple dollars to the bill. I paid for my friends so I didn't want to make a big deal aboutit. Instead, I emailed Frankie's after we got home with details including the check number. That was more than a week ago and Ihave yet to hear back from them in any way... even an apology. Fairly poor customer service follow up in my opinion. Luckily,we don't pass through Hayward that often. If you go, enjoy the pizza but watch your bill. Read more
The pizza was very similar to a number of different neighborhood places in Chicago. It?s classic square cut, a bit of acid in a... rich tomato flavored sauce. Well done and actually well priced. So, thumbs up there! Now, I?m not a fan of scathing reviews,but I can?t resist due to the level of disappointment. When you order wings in a restaurant there will be a variety of optionsand quality. Yet, the value is usually on par from place to place. Frankie?s, however really let us down. A FULL ORDER of wingsincluded only 6 (six) wings at $16.00. Sure I could have asked how many wings come in a full or half order, but for $16.00, didI say $16.00?, you?d think a buck a wing would be fair. I feel cheated. While I?m disappointed, I?m not totally dissatisfied.Everything was tasty. I?ll order pizza again. But until the wings are priced better, pandemic or not, I?ll stick with the pie. Read more
Because of the great reviews, we checked out Frankies. Delicious pizza. Fast service. Cozy interior. We?ve eaten here a few... times now. Like many of the locals, it?s our go-to for pizza when we are in Hayward. Thanks for the great pizza. Read more
This place blew away our expectations. It was tourist season and 2 places already turned our group aside for previous... reservations. If we knew how good this place was it would have been our top choice. The server was amazing taking orders fromevery direction while making top notch drinks at a reasonable price. This place changed the whole mood of everyone and left uswith a smile on our face. Their stuffed pizza is one of a kind and must be tried! Read more
This is the best pizza place in Hayward wi. Great prices, and delicious food. Stop in and check um out....you won't be... disappointed! Read more
I?m calling Google ! This place should get 10* Great local establishment I am so glad this was my introduction to Northwoods... food . We got the meats added onions mushrooms and green peppers. With anchovies on the side :) yes a real pizza joint hasanchovies! We will definitely be back Read more
Delicious Pizza and Great service. We ordered the Hawaiian Pizza and it was fantastic! We heard they had to close for awhile due... to lack of help, so we were very happy they were open again. We stop to eat every time we are in Hayward. Be patient and kind tothe servers they work hard! Read more