Reviews for Lost Land Lake Lodge in Hayward, WI
Had the fish fry last night. Truly was the best I have ever had at any restaurant. Crispy, generous serving with delicious... homemade tartar sauce, coleslaw, and crispy potato wedges. Pleasant server and owners. I'll definitely return next time I am inthe area. Read more
Food was amazing, we've been coming for decades when visiting the family cabin near Hayward. The 3 servers tonight did a great... job, especially Miriam and Amy who took a family photo of the 14 cousins and families. Can not beat the food anywhere. Read more
One thing you must try if you haven?t yet, brandy old fashioned sweet. It?s a must coming here. They make the best. In my... opinion! They won?t give up their secret recipe they say is made homemade recipe. The vibe is perfect and just a greatatmosphere. The staff is helpful and kind. Get the fish fry both broiled and fried. Also get the fries, idk why but they aregreat. Also if you are a non drinker try the cherry grenadine sprite! Take it easy and enjoy! Read more
The fish fry is delicious and a great thing is that it is offered every night, not just Friday. We have eaten many other menu... items as well and everything has been tasty. Owners are hands on and a very friendly couple. Read more
Nice view doesn?t make up for awful customer service. We were treated by the host as if the last thing he wanted to do was seat... customers. Came early and was told that there would be a 3.5 hour wait (it was a Friday night). We then asked for two separatetables, and he became rude and dismissive. There are many other options I?d consider before ever returning here. Read more
6/17/22 The food was very good however we felt extremely rushed. In our opinion, it is not necessary for waitstaff or table... clearers to constantly ask if we are done eating whilst holding our forks mid-bite literally about every three minutes. Everytime this happened I politely informed them all that we were still eating and would finish what we had on our plates and at ourtable. It was quite stressful. In just a short 30 minutes we were interrupted at least 12 times. Luckily improvements can alwaysbe made. Read more
Went there for a fish fry and I will say it was fantastic served family style and accessories. Very nice place besides and... friendly staff. I had the fried fish and my wife had broiled in butter both spot on.. Read more
Absolutely best food in northwestern Wisconsin. Prices hard to beat and quality of food tremendous. The best fish fry I've... had. Read more