Reviews for Yetty's Pizza in Herkimer, NY
So glad that my friend suggested that we eat at this little place tucked in the back of another big building. If you were... driving through town you wouldn't miss it. But if you're ever in the area I would definitely recommend stopping on him to getsome pizza. It's a cute and quaint place, definitely like the atmosphere. And we had an amazing waitress that was veryknowledgeable about the menu. Next time I'm in New York I will definitely stop on it again Read more
The best stuffed shells that I have ever had Eating them for breakfast now:) Pasta ( Al dente) and sauce just perfect and... ricotta w/lots of herbs yummy!!! Read more
Best Riggies around! I also love their upsidedown pizza and they make HUGE, great subs! Their other Italian dishes are also... excellent. I've never gotten a disappointing meal from Yetty's. We always order delivery and it has come quickly and perfectlyevery single time. Read more
We like Yettys, been there several times in the past. My wife wanted to go out for dinner and suggested Yettys. When we arrived... we sat without waiting. When she gave her order to the waitress, the waitress returned to tell her they were out of items 3times. Apparently the waitress didn't know these things. My wife settled for a simple pasta order. Overall I felt bad for mywife, because I have to live with her and didn't want to deal with her bad mood later on! Read more
NOT HAPPY!! We showed up to the restaurant at 8:10 on Saturday (yesterday, 7/30) only to be told that the dining room was... closed! The waitress said that the dining closed at 8pm, and refused to seat us! HOWEVER, their own website says that thedining room closes at 9pm!! Spoke to the manager, and she had an attitude about herself and said "No exceptions!!". She didn'teven apologize for HER mistake!! We drove from New Hartford, but he didn't care!! Obviously, she doesn't care about thecustomers!! Terrible attitude!! Oh well, there are many Italian restaurants in the area with better food, AND care about thecustomers!! Read more
Great food, good service. Mom and pop shop type of vibe.
2nd time visiting better than the first time. I got the shrimp riggies and my wife got the cheese pizza. The pizza she said was... fine but lacked cheese as seen in the pictures The riggies were a bit tasteless mild shouldn't mean no heat.(normally I go hotbut the last time it was not edible the amount of peppers they added.) The sauce was broken and had chunks of curdled heavycream in it. The bread hasn't changed its just heated no flavor and a little wirl added on tip with parm cheese. Read more
Ordered a sub and wings. Got home and my sub was soaked in mild sauce and the wings were burnt and dried out not because the... sauce leaked everywhere either!! Worst service ever!!!! Eating there weekly will come to an end. Called and the owner didn?twant to do anything not even a credit or simply replacing the food. What a joke. Good luck!!!! Read more