Reviews for Matoli's Pizza & Subs in Hernando Beach, FL

Visiting the area for a few days. Ordered pizza one night and was not disappointed. The woman that answered the phone was very... nice (and she was working alone when we called), the delivery was fast (and the driver was attentive) and the food was fabulous.You can tell the crust is homemade and the sauce had a delicious sweetness about it. Generous toppings. Not greasy at all!Ordered a cheese pizza, Hawaiian, garlic munchies and spaghetti. The prices were unbelievable too!! Would definitely order againnext time we are in town! Read more

Do not recommend this place due to poor customer service. My husband called to place an order for delivery and the guy that... answered the phone was very rude. When my husband was trying to give him the location for delivery the guy cut him off and hungup. We were excited to find a new pizza place but will not be ordering from here. Read more

I paid and left, then thought about the bill being over $30 when I expected $24. I went back and pointed to the menu on the... counter and was told that that one didn't count, the one with handwritten numbers on the side of his desk did. That added 25% tomy bill and then he charged another $1.10 because I used my credit card. Pizza wasn't bad, but the deceit was enough that I'llnever return. Read more

Ordered a stromboli, pepperoni pizza, american hoagie and cannolis. Everything was so delicious! My husband went in to pick up... the food, and said everyone was so kind! I would highly recommend eating here if you enjoy good authentic pizza! Read more

What a pleasant surprise. Just moved to HB, had been wanting to try Matolis but they didn't deliver (atleast that's what Google... led me to believe). So I decided to just go get it, called to place my order. They said "we deliver"... Nice surprise. I orderedthe deep dish chesse and a Greek salad. It was at my door in less than 30 minutes, another nice surprise. Well let me tell you,this is the best damn pizza I have had in years, just absolutely delicious. The sauce is amazing, has a great flavor, a bitsweet but not overly sweet. The Greek salad was outstanding as well. The price, cheap in my opinion. This place blows away anypizza delivery big chain by miles. Next I'll try a sub... You have a customer for life. Thanks! Read more

Here in Hernando beach for a weekend getaway and was in the mood for pizza. So glad we found this place. So so yummy! Greek... salad is big and the dressing has a sweetness to it I?ve never had in Greek dressing before, very good! Also got a Hawaiianpizza? freaking delicious! Cheesy, flavorful, crust cooked perfectly. Delivery was quick. 10/10 recommendation! Read more

Literally the best pizza I've ever had in FL! We were in town for just a few days on vacation. The "garlic munchies" are like... garlic knots, except even better. We even took the leftovers in the car with us and ate them on our drive home. Two of our groupare from Chicago and agreed it was amazing pizza. We purchased the regular crust and didn't try Matoli's Chicago style. If youlike pizza, I do think you'll be very happy! Great crust, great sauce, awesome topics - very, very good pizza! Read more

New to Hernando Beach and desperate to find comfort food... found absolute bliss with the pizzas we had delivered! The White... Pizza and the Meat lovers Chicago style were both a perfect choice. Delivered hot and fast. Well not hesitate or think twiceabout ordering here again. Read more