Reviews for Fenicci's of Hershey in Hershey, PA
O...M...G! What a phenomenal meal! Started with Shrimp Bruschetta appetizer and a side salad, followed by Homemade Lasagna, then... topped it off with Creme Brule Cheesecake. They even gave me a certificate for finishing the lasagna. I normally don't do "cheatdays" with my diet, but this exception was totally worth it! My wife wasn't feeling well enough to go out, so I'm getting atakeout Pappardelle Ala Vodka and the Creme Brule Cheesecake for her. Wow, just wow!! Read more
As a local, I truly appreciate having an Italian restaurant close-by that honors it's heritage and history through its food,... service and ambiance. Great for a special family event, a date or after-theatre / after-Hpark wind-down. Talented cooks and barstaff. Wait staff especially fun and ready to serve. As you can imagine, this place gets busy at times (especially in theSummer) but they seem to do their best to get you seated and fed. A little patience and kindness goes a long way. Worth thewait. After all, we're all in this together, right? ;-D Our meal was lovely. Celebrated my daughter's bday and collegegraduation. She adored her lasagna. Our mushroom pizza was on-point. Everyone has a "favorite pizza". I've done lots oftraveling for food (NYC, Chicago, SF, Italy) and Fenicci's pizza is in my top ten list. Different crust but darn good. Take achance and try the "Old World" (upside-down) Pizza. Shines a surprising light on the flavor of the SAUCE as well ascheese. They offer a huge salad for sharing. Forget the name so please ask. Great value for a family of 3-4. Have not yet triedtheir meat and seafood dishes but friends tell me they enjoy it immensely. Desserts - take your pick. All good. Outdoor diningextended to cooler months with updated heating system. In the winter, I enjoy tucking in at the bar area (stools and booths).Screen for watching the game. Classic Rock music generally playing which sets a relaxed, fun ambiance with which to try a newpasta dish. Thanks, Phil and crew for keeping Fenicci's at the top of local dining establishments! Read more
Fantastic meal! Food was out of this world! If you love Italian, you won't be disappointed. Service is top-notch and quick! I... would recommend reservations on a weekend. We were there on a Saturday without reservations and were lucky to get seated! It waspacked! Read more
Fenicci's was excellent. We had the sauteed mushrooms, calamari and mussels appetizers. All were delicious. The Risotto... Pescatore and the Basil Alfredo Seafood were wonderful. Frank was very friendly, helpful and extremely attentive. It is easy tosee why this establishment has been around since 1935! Can't wait to return! Read more
We totally loved this place. The food was very good and our server was so attentive and had a great personality!
Pleasantly surprised! We were quickly greeted and seated in one of the many dining rooms of the restaurant. The menu had quite a... few different options; pastas, pizzas, strombolis, and more. Both of our dishes tasted excellent and exceeded our expectations.We’ll definitely be back next time we’re in Hershey! Read more
I can't say enough about Phil and his wonderful staff. I brought 80 people for a luncheon and it totally exceeded my... expectations. The welcome was genuine, the food was hot and delicious, the service was with a smile and a great time was had byall! Phil was very responsive to get this all planned and he even put out birthday decorations for an extra touch. Thisrestaurant is a gem. Don't go to chain restaurants in Hershey, try this authentic spot and you will be happy you did! Read more
Our dining experience was very enjoyable. We started with the shrimp bruschetta which was very tasty. I had the wild mushroom... risotto my wife had the Sicilian risotto. Both were excellent. Our guests had tortellini blush and the butcher block. They wereboth fantastic. Our server was very efficient and friendly. If I remember correctly his name was Adam. Read more