Reviews for Margarita's Cafe Smithtown in Hicksville, NY
This restaurant has amazing customer service, ample free parking and a relaxing atmosphere. I special ordered each course since... I only indulge in Mexican food once a year. The margarita was balanced and fresh. The chips and fresh salsa are way aboveaverage. The salsa had just enough kick. For my starter, I went with black bean soup which was delicious. So obviously homemade- perhaps a long time tradional family recipe? Fresh sliced jalapeños on the side were firm and crisp. Just the way theyshould be. An entrée of beef chimachanga with refried beans and shaved lettuce & tomatoes was enjoyed as well. The menu isvast and highly appealing. Next time I find myself back in Syosset...OLE Read more
Some of the food was pretty good and other items were mediocre. If you are to get something I recommend getting the quesadillas... and not any of the salads. The salads are very bland. The place is relatively expensive but the service is quick. Read more
No reservations just walk right in and 1st come 1st served. Standard Mexican . Fairly sized portions were nicely flavored. One... of my pet peeves are that the cheese must be fresh! The cheese they used was a little old with a gooey texture and not firmlike the good fresh kind. Fix this and you will get another star! They were short on napkins so they would keep these speciallytrained extra large cats laying on the tables for us to wipe our hands. Read more
I just moved to the area - god awful this place. Do not drink the red sangria its full of syrup and a drop of red wine, i got... so sick it upset my stomach bad. The portions are a joke, huge plate such little food/presentation. The skirt steak was good butnot for the price. Service was so awful - to the point - not worth complaining - just laugh it off with your partner and makethe best of it. Server is always MIA in the beginning but ALWAYS on top and around when the bill is set & paid. Utensils aredisgusting and so messed up. We took 4 from the table next to us to have all 3 dirty, crusty old food on the knife & in betweenthe fork head. The only one who made it nice and showed they cared -a the busser. He was so sweet cared spoke with us, i ratherhave tipped him than our server. I will stick with East Meadow - cleaner, nicer, busier, & better portions Read more
This place is expensive and somehow the food has gotten worse. They were accommodating to my complaint but I cannot recommend... this location. The churros had literally like 4 pieces. Look at the picture. Would you be happy if you received any of that? Read more
Such a fun place with good food and music. Everyone was friendly and food and chips are tasty. Drinks are pricey but made well.
You want Mexican. This is the place to go. Great food, good service, very nice atmosphere, small bar area with great drink... mixes. Catching the amigos playing the music requested is a plus. Enjoy and relax here. ???????? Read more
This is about the worst run business and restaurant. I am not sure why anyone would choose this place with all of the other... wonderful dining options around. I ordered my son crispy chicken tacos. The restaurant never included them in the bag. I driveall the way home and then all the way back in the pouring rain. The hostess also the “investigator “ asked the person whopacked the bag and the chef. Both said it was in the bag. They acted like I was trying to steal a taco. Unfortunately theyclosed the case and I was forced to get my son dinner at another restaurant. Be warned. This place is terrible! Read more