Reviews for New York Slices in Highland Park, IL
Don't order here via GrubHub, they got my order wrong and refused to refund or replace it. The girl who answered sounded bored... during the call - she honestly sounded halfway asleep. I'm sad because this was my fave pizza joint for a long time Read more
Pizza is fantastic. Big foldable cheesy slices. As a former New York resident, I can say that this is the real deal.
I?ve been ordering from this place for the last 4 years and always had a good experience until tonight. The girl who answered... the phone was totally not in the working condition, had to repeat order three times. She said they ran out of ham at 4 pm, thatsweird. When we finalized order she just hang up not giving time frame when to expect. Called them an hour later and the guy saidthat driver is leaving right now. 40 min later called them back and he told me that he will check the refrigerator (have no ideawhy would he check refrigerator). Got back to me and told that driver is going back to the store and will pick up my pizza fordelivery as he did not do that before and will be another 45-55 min. I understand that is shortage of workers and people have tobe patient but 3 hours for pizza delivery i think its too much. I canceled the order and they lost me as a customer. Read more
It is true New York style pizza. Of course not the same as if I?m NY, but it gets the job done. If you?re a garlic dan, thee... spinach and garlic is very good; pepperoni was okay. We had a takeout order, quoted 30 minutes and it was warm and ready uponarrival - easy as can be. Read more
All the employees are so welcoming and kind. Especially maya. They got that Gucci Louie Vuitton pizza. Top tier. This is the... Usain bolt of pizza, the fastest and best. Read more
The thin pizza is very good. The flavor of the cheese is the best part. I do enjoy the sauce also. The garlic knot was ok in... flavor, but the dough was slightly dry to eat. It definitely could use something to dip it into. The Sicilian slice had goodflavor overall, although the crust was a but tough. Maybe it was sitting too long? I definitely would good back to this placethough. Read more
The pizza is actually really good. The delivery is good as well. I?m giving them a low rating because they don?t fulfill the... order properly. The first order was perfect. The second order they sent most of our order but also large cheese pizza insteadof a 10 inch gluten free pizza with additional toppings. I called and they corrected this and brought us the right one. Thethird and fourth time they fulfilled the order except they used regular crust for the 10 inch pizza I stead of gluten free. Idon't order gluten free to be fashionable, I order because of multiple health issues and this restaurant continually charges mefor the gluten free (which costs more), but does not give me gluten free and then I physically suffer because of it. Every timewe order we spend around $50 or so and always give at least a $20 tip. We will unfortunately have to take this businesselsewhere. Read more
Y'all really need to hire better staff or something, because wow... Lol. My boyfriend and I went here to get a couple of slices... of pizza, and the cashier was clearly high. He seemed super out of it and barely warmed up our pizza. Also, while we were there,two people came in to pick up their online orders and they were both told that there was no record of their order when theyclearly had their receipts. Not sure why there wasn't a manager around or something. So unprofessional. It's too bad becausethis place used to be really good. Read more