Reviews for Cottage Inn Pizza Hilliard in Hilliard, OH
Honestly...hard to believe we haven't had the pizza in the 4 1/2 years we've lived here. Very tasty and friendly employee I... spoke to on the phone. Pizza was as advertised and with my wife being a tough critic even she was super happy. Read more
My husband and I recently ordered here for the first time. It was the best pizza we?ve had in a very long time. Will be... returning! Read more
Favorite place to eat with amazing service. The owners son joe is very helpful and did a great job on my large pepperoni pizza.... The family that owns this location is very nice and I would recommend it to everyone! Read more
I ordered a large 14x1 pizza. Received a small ? Medium? The box is 12inches. Argued with the "owners son" Joe. He absolutely... refused to make this right. I will not be back. I hate being mansplained to. "Mam that's a large" please. Read more
My first order from Hilliard was because i eat downtown location alot i give it try and it was great. On monday around 4pm.... Second time today on Thursday at 5 which I took picture was the worst pizza ever. i had to eat because didnt have time toreorder. Burned, no parmesan butter on the crust. Just plain terrible. I cant believe i paid $31 for this sh.. Read more
It's really nice pizzeria at nice location. They have very good variety for pizzas, subs and salads. They have seperate... vegetarian menu which is awesome for me being a vegetarian. All pizzas come with cheese breadsticks. Read more
Ordered for the first time tonight. Awesome pizza. The sauce on the Pizza is fantastic. Great taste. We've lived in the area now... for over a year and have tried almost every pizza shop. This is definitely a must order pizza. Hand tossed????Ordered again thenext night because it was so good. Got the wings along with the Pizza..Fantastic wings. Read more
Really nice guy at the from counter but while taking my order, I saw one of the pizza makers eat toppings out of one of the... containers. That should have clued me in for bad things to come. The pizza crust was overdone which took away from anythinggood I could say about the toppings. An overall bad experience. Read more