Reviews for Rusty Bucket Restaurant and Tavern in Hilliard, OH

Went there three times so far. Service always fast, friendly, courteous and efficient. Food was good, I'd like to highlight the... pizza which was really delicious! They also have a great variety of up to 32 oz draft beers. I'll be back for sure! Read more

We arrived early for dinner, so there wasn't a crowd, though Wednesday is probably not a peak time anyway. Our server was very... friendly as well as being attentive, quick, and efficient. We enjoyed sitting by the warmth of the fireplace. The food was good,with the chicken being especially crispy on the outside. We ordered Chicken Parm and the Buffalo Chicken sandwich. Portionswere very generous! Read more

Top notch beer tap list with many local options. Buffalo chicken sandwich with blue chz crumble and juicy Lucy burger had TONS... of flavor! Excellent service. Read more

Location is a little tricky to get to. Service was decent. The server was very friendly and attentive. The food was delicious!... The fried pickles are one of my favorite things to get at Rusty Bucket. Read more

Went here for a lunch date and the food was overwhelming with flavor! I got the original (bucket) burger with cole slaw. The... burger stood about as tall as an old school alarm clock ??, maybe a little taller and was super fresh! The ingredients used feltlike they were fresh enough to be grown in their own backyard and the burger was big, beefy, and overflowing withjuicyness! Overall I give this place a 5 out of 5 stars because the food along with the service were fantastic and I woulddefinitely bring friends, family, and even strangers to come and enjoy the wonderful experience ???? Read more

Even after booking online I had to wait. But the staff was very courteous and friendly. The place is nice and cozy. Food options... are okay. Read more

There were 6 of us and we got 5 different things (shoot, forgot to take a pic of the appitizers!!). Everything was served hot... and delish!! The fish in the fish & chips was perfectly fried in fresh oil and the fries are excellent! The meatloaf andasparagus, pork tenderloin sandwhich were great and take a peek at the pizza! Very nice! The prices are on the slightly higherend but the portions for every meal was very generous! Ladies, you will want a box to take some home for tomorrow's lunch! Therestaurant is fun and festive and for larger groups, th seating was comfortable! Waiting on 6 ppl is not easy and we were ampedup. Our waitress handled us just fine!! Hats off to Tricia at Table 43 between 6 & 8 pm on 7/27!! Restrooms were clean andparking is ample with overflow if necessary. Heads up to future guests..the entrance is off Britton and you might have to go allthe way down to the roundabout and get into the giant "mall' lot and work your way back to the Rusty Bucket if traffic blocksyour entrance. Google has you trying to turn in off Cemetery Rd. I will try to get that fixed if given the opportunity.Absolutely excellent experience!! Ty RB!! Read more

The Mediterranean salad was amazing! I was surprised it was so big, I was expecting something way smaller! The menu is... hilarious! Loving the names of the foods. Let’s not forget how awesome our waiter was, she was very friendly, very warming andI would be more than happy to revisit and hopefully next time have room for sweets! Read more