Reviews for The Olive Tree Mediterranean Cafe in Hilliard, OH

I got a spicy Gyro and the meat was absolutely overcooked! The fries were stale and basically thrown back in the fryer setting... under a heat lamp very disappointed in the food and I payed 14.00 dollars for it! Restaurants need to be more considerate whenthey serve food like this I will definitely not be back for a long while! This place use to be excellent but now they don?t seemto care about quality! Getting home after a long day at work I just wanted a fresh meal but this wasn?t the case??? Read more

The spicy gyro is my absolute favorite, as well as the spicy feta dip. I ordered carry out and when I picked up my food it was... fresh and hot. They package everything really well and my order was correct. The gyro meat is sliced thick, tastes fresh and isnot greasy. The owners are so nice. Highly recommend The Olive Tree. Read more

Order was around $60. Only reason for the third star was presentation. Unfortunately for the type of cuisine the taste/flavor... was inadequate. Hummus was essentially tasteless, as were the falafel. Calamari was decent. Read more

I had a wonderful experience at this restaurant! The owner was very accommodating, I showed up probably 15-20 minutes before... closing time... I was from out of state and looking for some good food! I drove a half an hour from my hotel to this restaurant and was not disappointed in the food that I had! Thank you for going out of your way that night and for making my evening agreat one! Read more

I met a girlfriend at The Olive Tree for dinner tonight. We could tell they are short staffed and hustling to keep up - the... food was worth the wait! Our server was really sweet and took good care of us. The fire fries were so so good! I definitelyrecommend showing this restaurant support and dine-in or carry out! Read more

Shawarma and hummus was Absolutely delicious! We were visiting Columbus from Maryland and after almost 6 hours of driving we... arrived at this wonderful restaurant and tried almost the entire menu ?chicken Shawarma; spicy chicken with mushrooms; Lamb,chicken, and kafta shish kabob; fried calamari, the fire fries, and the cold appetizers Hummus, Tzatziki, Baba Ghanouj,Matbucha, Machmusa?even the salad tasted delicious ???? this was one of the best if not the best Mediterranean cuisine I haveever tasted?almost forgot the side of gyro pita was to die to for?anyways next time you are in Columbus you know where to go?BTW the service was excellent?the owner Ms. Lara was a great host Read more

The staff was super friendly and the food was incredible. Next time I?m in the Columbus area I will 100% be coming back. If you... love authentic Mediterranean food this is definitely the spot to go! The falafel is nice and moist and the tabouli is incrediblyfresh. The pistachio baklava is a must have! Five stars! Read more

Had a lovely dinner here with friends - they have a nice selection of Lebanese wines and all our entrees were delicious! The... seafood soup and chicken and mushrooms were particularly good. Read more