Reviews for Four Brothers Pizza Inn in Hillsdale, NY
Pizza was excellent, but I had to take away a star because the water and the water used for the sodas needs a filter. It has a... salty kind of taste. I couldn't drink anything. The service was nice, but the tables were sticky. I put a napkin down as aplacemat so I wouldn't have to touch the table. Besides these two issues, I enjoyed being there, but might not go back honestlybecause of the drinks. Read more
Waitress was great and fast service. Food was hot and delicious. The table did feel very sticky!! That's why not 5 stars.
Nicely spaced tables and cushy booths. Friendly though skeletal staff. In the rear is a small bar which attracts locals. The... food is delicious and affordable. Parking in paved lot around the restaurant. Bathroom narrow yet clean. Read more
Went out of our way to go here on the way to NJ because menu said it had gluten free pasta. We tried to order it and was... surprised when the server said that they had not had gluten free pasta in this location for a long long time, and they didn'tknow why it was still on the menu. Food we did get was okay, but not great, especially for the price. Read more
So, I havent been to this restaurant in about 25 years or so, was excited to revisit as an adult and see how good my memory... was... First thing to say, the food was very good, medium pizza, half cheese and half pepperoni. Excellent. Also had theAntipasto Salad, was also very good. One thing to note, the water is some of the worst tasting water I have ever had. Get apurifier! The problems are not the food, or the staff (young blonde girl was very polite and responsive), but the place needs amakeover.. badly. I swear it was literally the same tables and chairs from about 30 years ago... and they are in tatters. Theplace seems dirty. My young girls kept needing to change tables due to each one we were seated at having crumbs all over thebooth seats. Not to mention, a lot of the chairs and benches are ripped and/or taped over with a red type of duct tape. Myshorts were literally sticking to the tape on the booth. Very unpleasant and made me want to get out of there. Also, thebathrooms are horrible. So, to sum it up, the food is great (the water is horrible) and it seems extremely dated and needscleaning. Read more
Cheesy pizza and very tasty. The restaurant reminded me of my grandparents pizzeria and brought childhood memories. The service... was very good and the food was delicious. Read more
Good food at good value! Mostly American fare with some Greek items on the menu. About five beers on tap, and several others in... cans or bottles (Including local microbrews). Very friendly older waitress. Bar in back. Bulletin board for local news in thevestibule, along with coin-operated vending machines. Pay-phone on the wall by the bathroom, and in the bathroom is some oldcoin-operated vending machine. Several prepared foodstuffs are available for retail purchase. No wi-fi! Abundant parking in thelot out front. Read more
Love the Four Brothers Chain. They just know how to make food. Their Italian style dishes are fantastic with some Greek Flare.... Their pizza is fantastic, you can actually taste the sauce. Speaking if sauce, keep using it. It's the best ever. Good thingthere is one in Millerton. Bryce@ North East Ford Read more