Reviews for Bella Italia Pizza in Hilton Head Island, SC

TERRIBLE. The problem is the ingredients themselves. The Vegetarian pizza was covered in 'old' breaded deep fried eggplant. It... tasted tasted like fryer oil. We could not eat it. The kids had a Sausage pizza. The sausage was not good. The cheese is notgood. The crust is just OK. It will be awhile before my family agrees to go for pizza again. Read more

Really fun atmosphere with friendly staff. Our food took a while to come out but it was well worth the wait! Football was on the... TV so that was a plus. Read more

Usually one of our favorite places to go on the island, we went tonight they had only one sever on a Saturday night and once a... party of 11 arrived we lost our server. Wanted more garlic bread to replace the burnt bread but he didn?t come back until theend of the meal. Same for drink refills he went to get a sprite refill then next thing you know he?s outside taking the partyorder only other person I saw was I?m assuming the owner or manager either way she was more concerned with sitting down androlling silverware then the customers sitting with empty glasses. Honestly a very disappointment experience. Left the guy threedollars and honestly only did that because he was glaring over my shoulder as I filled in the tip. That was the most attentivehe was for the whole meal. Good food horrible experience not worth the money. Read more

First time getting a pizza from here. It was delicious! The cheese tasted amazing and the crust was perfect. We got a large and... it easily fed 3-4 people. Staff was prompt and kind. Read more

The service and food are exceptional, wait staff courteous, and timely. This was our first time and would highly recommend!... There were six in our party, we had appetizers, salads and entrees, which all arrived within minutes of being seated. Theappetizers and entrees were piping hot and delicious. Serving sizes were exceptionally large and enough to share or take homeleftovers. Read more

Delicious Pizza. But we waited a long time for the food..... Waitress was nice.

Terrific place to eat! I ordered the chicken parmigiana, and it was one of the best I?ve ever had. Daniel the waiter was also... one of the nicest waiters I?ve ever seen! He was funny and congratulated me on my order selection. The whole Italian atmospherewith old time music was very pleasant. The service was also excellent and the prices were reasonable. I would totally recommendgoing here! Read more

Quality ingredients, good service, and good prices. This place is a quality Italian restaurant in the Hilton Head Island area. I... didn't try their authentic Italian food nor did I eat at the restaurant due to COVID-19, but based on the nature of the staffand the clientele, it looks like it's a rather quality experience. I ordered a cheese pizza, regular wings, and a chef's salad.The salad was surprisingly full of meat, and additional toppings and Even though I got this as a pickup item, the lettuce wasstill very crunchy and not too soggy or wet. With the dressing on the side it definitely helped, but you can also tell thatafter cleaning the lettuce, they do a good job of drying off the water versus letting it make the salad too soggy. The regularwings were something that my daughter requested and for an Italian place they were actually really good. They reminded me of astandard wing you would get at Buffalo Wild Wings. The buffalo sauce was well done and had an abundance of extra sauce, the bluecheese was rather standard and the wings themselves were large, meaty and perfectly cooked so the meat remained juicy. Thecheese pizza was the only reason why I ended up dropping from a five star to a four star. Though it was very well seasoned, andhad a large amount of mozzarella cheese that was very high quality, the dough itself was much thicker than I'd typically prefer,being a NY Style or thin Italian Style pizza fan. There was also much less sauce than my wife and I prefer, making it verycheese heavy and thick. If they just added a little more sauce and made the dough thinner this would be one of the better pizzaoptions in the Hilton Head area. Overall very good food & service and we'd likely come here again. Read more