Reviews for New York City Pizza in Hilton Head Island, SC

Loved the pizza! We had the New York-style pizza and the Chicken Marsala.The food was amazing ? super fresh and super tasty. The... server and other staff members were friendly, too. Overall, it?s a great place for a meal out! Read more

One of the best experiences we have had in a while! Thank you so much for a great meal out. Huge shout out to the cooks! The... NY-style pizza is one of the tastiest pizzas I've ever had. The pasta was great too, you can definitely taste how fresh it is! Really delicious food at an amazing price ???? Read more

Have been here twice this year while staying at a nearby resort and the pizza is great! The pan pizza dough is really good. Only... complaint is they don't deliver to where we were staying 10 minutes away. But it's close enough to pickup and is well worth it. Read more

Their New York-Style pizza was absolutely incredible. I?ll be thinking about it for weeks. The salads were tasty too, I loved... the Greek salad. No complaints about the service or the restaurant either, a solid pizza spot. Read more

I had been craving Pizza for the prior 2 days, and had already purchased food when I noticed this restaurant on the way back to... the truck. Yes, I went in for a slice, and it was worth it! Staff was friendly, helpful and efficient. Environment waswelcoming. Kids were making their own pizza which was adorable. Indoor and outdoor seating as well as an indoor and outdoorbar. Definitely a relaxed spot to enjoy a bite! Read more

We just ordered from this restaurant and ordered a large cheese pizza and breadsticks. We received a very cold pizza with... mushrooms, sausage and onions instead of our cheese pizza (which my kids will not eat). Our breadsticks were also cold andcovered in sauce which had spilled out all over the bag. I tried calling the store and nobody answered. Edit: I had spoken tothem the following day and had been told they'd mail me a gift card due to the mistake. I was going to update this oncerecieved, but still haven't gotten over a month later. Will update if it ever comes lol Edit 2: The restaurant reached out andapologized last week and did send me a gift certificate for the full amount I paid! Read more

Not sure about the recent reviews, but don?t listen to them! Dominick provided wonderful service and great conversation while we... dined in. We had the deep dish and the cheese was awesome! Great stringy-ness to dough ratio. Our daughter is picky about pizzacheese and loved it. The deep dish had a great crust, crispy bottom and fluffy top so we had the best of both worlds. Woulddefinitely come again and order take out if we were local. The prices match a local joint and not a huge chain. Don?t listen tothe Karens and enjoy a great little place while you are vacationing. Bonus?right next to a Publix and ABC ?? Read more

I hate to give 1 star reviews but the spiders, dead bugs and small flies on the ledge of our table warrant it. If they can?t... take care of the front of house, what is going on in the rear. Read more