Reviews for Butterfield Stage Co. Steak House in Holbrook, AZ
I was looking forward to this place and the decor did not disappoint. Country music playing was great. We dined on a Monday... night and when we arrived at 6pm the place was empty. Staff were attentive. The bar was closed. My husbands ribs were good. Iordered filet Mignon and half the steak was gristle and completely raw. Could not eat it. I did mention this to the wait staff.The waitress must have been offended by my tip and rolled her eyes at me when I handed it to her. Overall I loved the westernretro decor and music, being overseas visitors it was a shame there were only two other diners when we were there. Would havebeen great to sit at the beautiful bar which was closed. Thank you we did get one complimentary dessert for staying at BradsDesert Inn. Read more
A nice place to stop and have dinner after visiting the Petrified Forest National Park. Cosmetically, the building could use... some updates (although I liked the red neon), the salad bar was closed (which caused a couple to walk out, LOL) and the airconditioner was out -- but the food was very good and the server was phenomenal. Read more
Simply Outstanding. Old School meets....Old School!! Great food, great staff and an Old School Charm you will be hard pressed to... find anywhere else. Please go have a ribeye on the wood fire.....scrumptious. The Prime Rib was super good too. Read more
Had a great dinner here! Only two downsides...they had a limited menu which meant no New York, Ribeye or Ribs. Sadly, we had... been looking forward to a New York, Ribeye and Ribs all day. The salad bar was also not up and running. The food we did get wasfantastic. Opted for the T-Bone and filets. All were cooked perfectly, the veggies crisp and tasty as well as the baked potato.They did offer a small side salad and bread in lieu of the salad bar. Service was super friendly. Overall we really enjoyed ithere and hope the limited menu is the last dregs of Covid/supply chain issues. Support local businesses! Read more
Loved the old building, sign, windows, etc.. Waitstaff and host very personable and smiling. Excellent food and rolls are warm... and tasty! Read more
We checked out Butterfield Stage Co.Steak .first the music was country, listening to it was nice ???? the place was cozy. Clean.... The bread (rolls) were hot,delicious. dont worry about extra butter they give you all works out ????. I ordered BarbecueRibs,baked potatoes & vegetables. (The Barbecue ribs looked hungry mans meal but,no. ). The ribs came off the bone easily,justthe right amount of Barbecue & it had little sliced onions on it I loved it.veggies were cooked just perfectly. My otherordered steak,baked potatoes & veggies. I took a bite of his steak was Delicious. Over all of this experience it was Delicious.Employees were polite. Come and try this establishment and you'll agree.???? Read more
This is an old style steakhouse with interesting decor. Unfortunately they have no AC, so it gets warm inside. The... hostess/waitress was nice and polite. I wish she was wearing a mask though. Didn't see any other customers or staff wearmasks. We started with Buffalo wings and mozzarella sticks. The wings were tasty, but kinda cold. The mozzarella sticks weregood. The steaks were very good! I had a T-bone steak that came with bread, grilled veggies and steak potatoes. They have adecent selection of bottled beers as well. The prices are a bit steep. If you're worried about covid and staying safe, this isprobably not the place for you. We had a quick dinner and left. Read more
Recently visited this restaurant while in town seeing my daughter. Went in later on a Thursday night and there was plenty of... open seating. Our food was great, but the reason I?m here is because our server, Sarah, went above and beyond anything weexpected. It was my daughter?s birthday and they made the experience excellent, going as far as to turn all the lights out inthe restaurant when they brought her a cake with a candle. I will be forever thankful that she made her day so special. Read more