Reviews for Johnny's New York Style Pizza in Hickory Flat, GA
Went with the wife and kids. Was nice to see a low carb pizza crust on the menu, will be back.
They used to have great pizza, now it's all way over salted and undercooked.
It's just food. It does not taste good. Mellow Mushroom is far better. Their lunch special is two slices for $6.99. With one... topping. If you wanted to add extra toppings like I do, feta & artichoke they charge a $1.19 each, so $6.99 ends up becoming $12for two slices of pizza, definitely not worth that price. I waited four years after living in the area to go there. I will notbe going back. Maybe their other food keeps them in business. But it definitely is not the pizza. Read more
Thursday at 6:45pm...place is hopping, everyone happy, smells great and the wait staff and cook(s) are all having a great time... while impeccably completing orders! I mean, these folks clearly have a good rythym and process here. Food was fresh, wellplated, and delicious. I'm originally from New York... This is how it's done "y'all"! Great job, I will Def come back, thankyou so much for the wonderful experience Read more
On a stormy Thursday night, I walked into Johnny's New York Style Pizza for the first time and even with the bad weather, found... the restaurant filled with patrons. I was seated quickly and ordered the Johnny's Italian Special pizza. O.M.G. THE BEST. Service was beyond excellent. For great food and friendly service, stop by and see for yourself! Read more
Absolutely love the staff and the owner here. Always go out of there way to greet me when I walk in. I feel like Norm from... cheers as they all yell Roooddddd. I read the Dumpster Fire comment and found it incredibly amusing. And in true fashion,the awesome folks even bought a dumpster fire trophy they proudly display (see pic) as a reminder how well they actually takecare of their customers. They are everything you want from a home town place. Wouldn't trade a thing about it. Nicholas ithink is better suited for A Quick Tripp pizza perhaps. Read more
Went there with a large party this evening. Service was amazingly slow but food was excellent
I ordered an extra large half cheese half beef with extra cheese. I ended up getting a Extra large all beef with extra cheese. I... called and they said they could take 20% off if we ordered a new pizza. I said that?s not okay so they put me through to amanager and I told her the situation and she said we can give you a medium pizza THIS ONE TIME! As is we did something wrong. Do better Johnny?s. Read more