Reviews for Duffy's Tavern, Bar, and Grill in Holmes Beach, FL

Nice off the beaten path place for a great hamburger and cheap cold beer. Probably the best meal I had while visiting the... Island. Read more

Burger was OK, not much flavor, lack of fries or onion rings a downer. Always heard raves about the Burgers. Frankly five guys... is much better. Nice little island bar vibe. Read more

This is my kind of place. I'm mad at myself for not finding it sooner in prior trips to AMI. Unpretentious, reasonably priced... and very good burgers. To go was a breeze, we had it twice in the week we were on AMI. Thought the potato salad was great aswell. Read more

Great cheeseburger, had the Texan BBQ burger. Good cheap beers, wonderful ambiance. Service could be nicer but no-fuss. Quick... service, good potato salad. Fries would be cool but only chips or potato salad or cole slaw. Read more

This place is so quaint. The burgers are phenomenal they have other sandwiches that I haven?t tried yet but everything I?ve had... there is good. The chili is amazing and it?s homemade, they have homemade white bean soup, and homemade chicken noodle soup.Staff is friendly and the prices are perfect. Read more

Definitely the hole in the wall joint that everyone else describes. The burgers are very good, but it is disappointing they... don?t have French fries. Especially since their pulled pork is VERY good and would be amazing served over fries with some meltedcheese. Just sayin. Also, be warned if visiting as a tourist as most do? I?ve witnessed locals/regulars being served ahead ofothers waiting at the bar. I mean, I appreciate loyalty? but it?s tough to make new loyal customers with that kind of behavior. Read more

Was recommended this gem by family while we were staying a week in Anna Maria Island. Cash only so make sure you have it or not... they have a ATM inside. Family owned since 1971 and there is a reason they are still going strong. The burgers are amazing andvery reasonable in price. The staff is very friendly and it was cool just looking at all the cool history inside. We cannotwait to go back. Read more

This is a tavern. Cash only! Typical rock and roll soundtrack, jovial folks imbibing alcohol at the bar and neon signs glowing... with the promise of all that beer can bring. Definitely one of those places to rub elbows with a local crowd. The table wasgreat and the prices were reasonable in comparison with other local eateries. Grab a menu make a selection and walk up to anempty place at the bar if there is one then give the tender your order. The drinks will be passed over the counter and after youreturn to your table the food will be delivered to you when it has been prepared. It did not take long for the burgers toarrive. They do not have fries but the potato salad was nice maybe the coleslaw would be good as well but we did not order it.The burgers were very good above average to be sure. All around a good experience even for this non-alcoholic individual. Read more