Reviews for Fat Tomato in Holyoke, MA
Great pizza and probably one of the best meatball subs I?ve ever had!! The crust on the pizza was what I?ve been looking for in... this area! It?s even better re-toasted! We stopped in on a rainy Monday night and the owner was very welcoming! Outstandinglittle hidden gem! ?????????? Read more
No exaggeration, this is the BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD! Desserts and salads in his fridge are delicious and delightful. We... tried the grinders once. My wife loved hers, I thought mine was decent but average. The pizza is the real treat here, superiorto all other others we have ever tried! I do not recommend ordering from the website. The "Slice" app is terrible, and you getovercharged. Just call in your order if possible. Read more
The owner is committed to high quality ingredients and food preparation. Not the friendliest fellow but the food is an... excellent American style interpretation of the Neapolitan classic with a bit of Sicilian-American thrown in (it?s spicier then uor Italians might be use to..) Read more
The pizza is delicious but the owner has terrible customer service skills. I ordered via the app and was given a time of... 7:17-7:32 for pick up and that I would receive a notification when it was ready. Previous times I have ordered and shown upbefore getting my notification and have waited. My pizza was sitting on a wire rack when I arrived at 7:40. He placed it in thebox added more toppings and handed it to me. The box was cold. When I got home and opened the box the shredded cheese wasn?teven melted. My pizza was cold and when I called to ask if I made a mistake and ordered a cold pizza somehow. I was then told Iwas 15/20 min late picking up my pizza. He offered to make another one i said ?i just want to know the proper temp to reheat it, I don?t want to have to drive back?. I stated that it was cold to the touch, it was 7:46 when I called. He then told me ?ohcome on, it?s not that cold, it?s probably been a half hour from the time you picked it up? that?s when I said thanks and hungup. Read more
Every time I eat here the pizza has been excellent. Their "Ma's Garden" pizza may be the best pizza I've ever had anywhere!... It's a no-meat pizza loaded with lots of delicious sauteed veggies, pesto, and just tastes sublime (I love meat too but thismakes you forget all about it!). They also have an excellent cauliflower crust you can substitute on any small pizza. Read more
I cannot say enough about this neighborhood gem, The owners are totally committed to serving a high-quality product and they... have some of the best grinder rolls in the area ! They are also super down to earth and generally concerned about your diningexperience with them. If you have not had the opportunity to visit I would highly recommend doing so Read more
Tried Fat Tomato on a recommendation and it was AMAZING. Best pizza I've had in the Holyoke and Easthampton area by far. We got... the "tour of Italy" and it was a beast. It must have weighed twice as much as an average pizza and was very filing. I canusually eat half a large no problem, but was only able to finish two slices. That other review that said the pizza was nasty?Must be a competitor because everything was fresh and delicious. Pizza too salty? No way. I also loved the crust. My wifethought it was a bit tough, but still loved the taste. We had a 20 minute drive home with it in a heat bag so I bet it tasteseven better fresh out of the oven. Can't wait to try their sicilian! Just look at all that delicious ricotta! Read more
Looks like your typical pizza shop , tastes like heaven! Amazing crust crispy. Yet fluffy somehow ?! The mozzarella is made... locally. Just an unexpected pizza gem . Read more