Reviews for Flaherty's Three Flags Inn — Honeoye Falls in Honeoye Falls, NY

Flaherty's is a gorgeous and popular restaurant in Honeoye Falls. It is set right beside the creek. Seasonally there is outdoor... porch and patio seating. Also chairs along the creek to view ducks , geese, and other wildlife. Beautiful view. Inside there are2 large dining rooms, a beautiful full bar, booth seating, TV's and a lovely fireplace around the edges. The food is wonderful. I had the largest side salad I've ever seen, with generous blue cheese crumbles, delicious Mac and cheese and a glass of wine.It was fabulous. The take out container was so nice you can reuse it and add it to your plastic storage containers. If you comefor St Patrick's day you will see some wait staff in kilts and a live bagpipe performance! Currently there are really classyclassic Christmas decorations up all around. Very festive and beautiful. It is a great place to celebrate a special event orbirthday also. You will love Flaherty's. It is one of our gems in Honeoye Falls. Read more

We had a very competent and attentive young server named Matt. The food was delicious and the portions were generous. My... eggplant parm was enough for three meals! My husband ordered the prime rib. The cook was as requested and the meat was tenderand well seasoned. The only criticism I have is that the booth we sat in was kind of dirty. There were some cobwebs on the wallnext to me and the seat needed to be wiped down. Read more

My sister and I went here for lunch....it was AMAZING. We got the lobster ???? bisque...the best we've ever had. We also got... the artichoke french and the reuben sandwich. It was all fresh and hot. They were extremely busy...and we can see why. We'lldefinitely be back. Read more

It was amazing service. The food was pretty good. We've been there once before and the second time around was much better. It... was a quiet evening and the server was amazing. The espresso martini was super strong so no complaints ???? I had chicken andbiscuits and it made me feel at home. Read more

Went to the Finger Lakes region for a mini get away with family and found Flaherty's. The food was great but the staff was... fantastic! Very personable and friendly! Highly recommend! Read more

Take our seems to be hot or miss lately. Tonight things weren't packaged correctly and gravy spilled all over bread. Hamburger... was raw in the middle. Like literally raw! They were clearly short staffed because their were so many open tables yet walk outna were 10-15 min waits. It's time for myself and family to reevaluate our choices. Read more

We had such a nice 45th Anniversary dinner, sitting on the lovely porch, overlooking the creek. Absolutely delicious scallops... and chicken French dinners. My husband loved the lobster bisque as well. Our waitress was awesome, which added to the greatexperience. We'll be back ????????????! Read more

Absolutely the BEST fish fry I've had in ages! Huge portions, perfectly cooked, fantastic service. Great tap list, came in... earlier for lunch and had an outstanding burger. This place is fantastic! Read more