Reviews for Scarfallotos Towne House Diner Restaurant in Honesdale, PA

Pros: Convenient parking, Outdoor dining area is really decent for a diner, a cold mug is provided with bottled beer Cons:... Hostess took us to a table , plopped the placemats,napkins, utensils and menus in a pile & left. We both ordered a sald, onewas acceptable, the other had many browned pieces of lettuce, server was not apologetic but said she would replace it if sodesired. Rolls were very dry. Chicken Parm was not great but acceptable. Turkey platter was served with a very wiltedgarnish. Turkey was dry over tasteless dressing, sweet potatoes were good, don't know about the carrots b/c I only got ONEquarter-sized slice of carrot. Requested beverage refill never arrived. A 4% fee is added to cc payments. We paid $45 for alousy experiece. I have no idea why this place is popular and won't return. Read more

I've always had great meals at this place. The homemade soup keeps me going back. Unfortunately the last time I was there, I... felt like I was in the middle of a employee fued. Waited for a table (no problem, expected on a Saturday night), when we wereshown to our table it wasn't one table but two separate tables. We asked if we could combine this table or add chairs to atable. No, you can sit at two tables or go back outside and wait another 30 minutes. Didn't want to Make it a big deal so weate. The kids kept getting up, wanting to be with us, it wasn't the experience we wanted. When we got the check they addedgratuity because we were a table of 8. Talk about adding insult to injury. In this day and age going out as a family is a treat,my daughter spent $150, won't do that again anytime soon. Read more

Do not ask for water! Order bottled water or soda, worst water ever, even the ice in the sodas made them taste funny. Came in... for a quick bite, the cheese pizza by the slice was hugh, fresh, and tasty! The specialty pizza slices were also great! We willbe back for the pizza! Read more

The young hostess who seated me seemed annoyed that I asked to be seated at a different table; I am not comfortable at a high... table with the high "barstool" type chairs. My waitress quickly made up for those negative moments, however. She approached mewith an upbeat and friendly attitude, was helpful with my menu selections, and was attentive to any needs I had during mymeal. I had the boneless chicken, an ample portion that was quite good. I also had a medium-sized specialty pizza, which wasgood - but I may have enjoyed it more had it been baked a little longer and had a crisper crust. Read more

Excellent Blue Cheese and Bacon cheeseburger. The place is really nice with a train track around the ceiling! The water wasn?t... good but the food was excellent along with the service. Highly recommended and would definitely return! Read more

They?ve screwed up my order for the last time. Pizza is decent sometimes and other times they skimp on the toppings. Today they... screwed up my order again, even though I was asked to repeat it on the phone, then when I get there both of the toppings Iordered were incorrect. Plus apparently they no longer offer one of the toppings I requested. You?d think they?d mention that onthe phone instead of just throwing on whatever they like. They also did not offer a discount when I told them about this. Weneed to find a new pizza place in Honesdale, unfortunately the pickings are slim? Read more

This place is amazing, the food is delicious and the staff are friendly, we had a great time

Great diner for the family to visit. Food was amazing. Chili was so good and I inhaled the spinach and feta omelet. So many... things on the menu that I contemplated moving to the town for a month or so to try them all. Breakfast all day, even have apizza menu. Great kids menu to boot. Read more