Reviews for Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza in Hoover, AL

Literally sold us a pizza with rotten tomatoes. I bit into the rotten tomato. When we tried to call and get them to take the bad... pizza and make us a new one, they refused. They said they weren?t going to ?make us a free pizza?. I?m trying to GIVE THE BADPIZZA BACK! He won?t give us the money back or give us a pie without rotten ingredients. I will never be back. NEVER! Update:As you can see, they have responded asking me to reach out via the email they shared. Well, guess what! The email addressdoesn?t exist, and neither does the website that the email is supposed to be linked to. Read more

Definitely one of our go-to places when we want good pizza. Service is great and food never disappoints. Added bonus - Tuesday... night is Bingo night. You can enjoy good food and have fun with a small crowd of folks hoping to win. Read more

My girlfriend and I went there after the dinner rush on Friday night, so we were seated quick. She and I kept it simple - two... beers; an order of garlic knots (excellent); Hawaiian pizza with jalapeños and banana peppers for me (excellent); and a plateof spaghetti and meatballs for her (she really liked it!). Drinks and food were great. Big shoutout to our server, Isaac. Thatguy was the damn bee?s knees. He was super cool and friendly; he made sure we were taken care of; and he was helpful. If you seeIsaac there, give him and high-five and a good tip. (In fact, tip all your servers well.) Read more

Always have had great pizza from this location! Really good crust and cheese. App's are also good and the beer is cold with a... ok local selection. Read more

Tried Johnny Brusco?s tonight while at work. Advertised as a New York style pizza. Crust was crispy with a chewy center. Cheese... was hot and gooey. Pepperoni was rather bland. Red sauce was sweeter than I would prefer. Supposed to be brick oven baked butcrust was very evenly cooked as an oven would cook. Unlike other brick oven pizza I have had in the past. Overall pizza was OKwith descent flavor, but pricey for a 12 inch pie. A pepperoni and a margarita pizza cost me upwards of $32 before tip. Read more

Service was really good! Everybody was very friendly!his! Was a very cozy place to go have a bite to eat! I will definitely be... back in the future! Read more

I really enjoyed dinning in at the Johnny Brusco?s. We were greeted immediately upon entering and were sat quickly. The service... was awesome and our waiter Stephen did an amazing job. We ordered veggie and cheese pizzas and they were delicious and perfectlydone. I will come back here again! Read more

My husband found this restaurant on local flavors, so we decided to give it a try. It's a little hard to get in and out with... traffic. It was pretty busy for a weekday (dine-in and pick-up), so I took that as a good sign. The menu is a lot to take in, soit took a while to decide what to get. I ordered the house stromboli. It was completely stuffed with toppings and cheese andhot! The marinara sauce was chunky which I liked. The sprite tasted fresh. Some restaurants have flat or off tasting fountaindrinks, but not here. Now the menu says the cheesecake has assorted flavors, but when we asked our server, she let us know it'splain cheesecake. The taste was different but not in a bad way. The texture is really creamy and smooth...almost softened butterlike. I'm convinced the crust is nilla wafer and not graham cracker which was a pleasant surprise! I wish there was a strawberryor maybe blueberry fruit topping. Read more