Reviews for Great American Cookies in Horseheads, NY

Disappointed that we couldn?t be served a custom doozie because they put away the frosting. I work in food and am usually... understanding, just shocked they would pack up with half an hour left in the day. Read more

Had some double doozies made with the chocolate frosting delicious as always if you got a sweet tooth that is

Excellent service. Very quick. Sent me a picture of the finished product.

I been getting cookies from here for over 20 years now. The owner or manager is great. She?s very good at what she does and goes... out of her way to make sure your happy. Great customer service and a good cookie. Great place!!!! Read more

Almost $5 for two cups of ice water! Tap water and ice in a cup. I understand charging for a cup but that much!! Charged me... for 2 large sodas. Never going back. Owner was rude. Not the first time I had a bad experience there. Read more

The best cookies you will ever have and the staff is awesome keep up the great work thank you for your commitment to perfection... you guys are the best Read more

My family LOVES these cookies! And they're really good about doing oddball designs if you give them a good sketch to work from:)

I stop buy when I'm by this store to buy the wife cookies. I've been doing it ever since I met her 10+ years ago. The cookies... are great. Read more