Reviews for Pudgies Pizza in Horseheads, NY
Don't get me wrong, pudgies is a great place to go if nobody in your party knows what they want, or maybe you just like Heavy... food, but overall there is a better restaurant for every food item they sell within 5 minutes of this location. Wings go tonicks, sandwiches go to on a roll, pizza go to Giuseppe's. It has its place but to me that place is for children after a ballgame, not for people who are looking for great food. Read more
My favorite childhood pizza place going on 45 years now. Always make the trip off the expressway when I'm back in the finger... lakes. Not like any other pie. Read more
Used to be so much better. I rave about their pizza and wings, but then it turns out terrible. Also, one fish fry is now like... $35. Read more
These guys are awesome! I had ordered online for the first time and didn't realize ordering a cheese and then selecting garlic... as a topping meant there would be no sauce and my lil guy is a stickler for sauce and cheese. They remade a pizza for us rightaway free of charger to fix it and save the birthday boy's party. Would give them 6 stars for their service ?? They definitelygained a loyal customer! Read more
This place is always hopping they have the most amazing fish dinner on Friday nights. I prefer this one over the one in Watkins... Glen. The staff at the Horseheads pudgies are so friendly and outstanding they do an awesome job. Read more
Have loved Pudgies since I was a child and now, as an adult who no longer lives in the area, it is still always my first stop... when I come to town to visit family. We are often here twice a day, everyday that we are in town! We were in town for a familyfuneral this weekend. We ordered a couple pizzas, including a sheet, and there was a mix up with the order which we didn'tnotice till we got home. I called and spoke to Brent. He was apologetic and fixed the problem quickly, without any hesitation,and went above and beyond. I have lived in the NYC/NJ area now for most of my adult life. I KNOW good pizza....nothing beatsPudgies and the HHDS location is the BEST! Read more
Very busy pizza shop. But I can see why. Its the first time I have ever been to Pudgies. The Stromboli was packed full and... delicious. Bread sticks were good. Wings were perfectly spicy and sauced. Blue cheese dressing was awesome. The canolis werehonestly the best I've had. It was not overly sweet. Im not a big canoli fan usually, but Pudgies did a phenomenal job. Staffwas friendly and personable. We ate outside at the tables they setup. With social distancing applied.. Which was excellentbecause you got to see the cute town of Horseheads, NY. Historical Hanover square is well kept very quaint very cute. Thank youPudgies. Read more
Ordered a chicken wing pizza all the chickens in one spot on the pizza not even spread out sitting on top of the cheese... undercooked I?m going Southside from now on Read more