Reviews for 1653 Pizza Company in Huntington, NY
Had a great time here. Food and drink was good. The waiter and waitress were nice and friendly. They asked if our puppy need... water too. Read more
It was hard to decide on a pizza to share because they all sounded so good, but fortunately they let you do half and half! We... had Spinach on one side and Bacon jam on the other. I preferred the spinach. Wines by the glass were very good. The suppliappetizer was not described well. It was not clear that it essentially was rice balls. Disappointing at $15, which is why thisreview is only 4 stars. Otherwise: fun vibe, friendly staff, clubby music, outdoor seating. Read more
I really wanted to like this place more because the vibe is very nice, but the food just wasn't amazing sadly. Our waitress was... very nice. We started w the fried shrimp and calamari. It was pretty good. I don't think fried shrimp works as well as friedcalamari but it wasn't bad. We had the White pizza and parma pizza. The flavors were really nice but I have to agree with theother reviewers that the dough is super soggy in the middle and its a wet mess. Finally, I had the squid ink spaghetti withclams. They didn't have the squid ink and just gave me regular spaghetti which wasn't a big deal because the regular spaghettinoodle was actually very nice. The dish itself was the most disappointing part of the night. It had lots of garlic and oil andsomehow still had no flavor. We added salt and cheese to try to doctor it and it still just wasn't very good. For the mostexpensive pasta dish, you really need to make sure it's solid. Drinks were nice though! Read more
Ordered a couple pizzas for take out, was ready in 15 minutes. The pizza was not good. Quite soggy and very thin. The oven temps... are off, the pizza had a generous amount of burnt char on the crust but there is zero color on the rest of the pizza and thetiny bit of cheese wasn't even melted. Dough and sauce are too salty. Sauce needed the most help, just tasted like tomato saucestraight out of a can. And $17 for a 12 inch pizza that hardly had any cheese on it was ridiculous, like paying $17 for half aloaf of bread with some ketchup smeared on it. Not sure where all the good reviews are coming from but there is much betterpizza anywhere else. Read more
Featured this week: 1653 Pizza Company ???? 80 Gerard St, Huntington, NY 11743 ???????? If coal fired pizza is your thing... this is a must try. Everything we ordered was delicious. The calamari was perfectly cooked & flavorful. The pork belly skewerswere really unique & paired so well with the homemade pickled cucumber chips. The pizza is what really blew us away. The BronxBacon is an absolute must try. Topped with vodka sauce, bomba chili, and house made bacon jam you get heat, sweet, and savoryall in one! Read more
This place is pretty good! Yummy tasting focaccia and seasoned well! Then we got frozen limoncellos which tasted great (great... summer item I think). Then we got a red pie a white pie and 2 pasta dishes all tasted superb. The atmosphere is nice as well!Just a little pricey but to be expected for a sit down place. But yummy food would definitely go back. Read more
The pizza similar to what you will find in Italy. If you like American style and brick oven maybe try Anthony’s. The ambiance... is wonderful and service was very friendly. Great cocktails!! Read more
This is some of the best pizza I have ever had - period! I lived in Italy for many years and this is some of the best! The... White Clam pizza is OFF THE CHARTS! The Parma pizza is ridiculous! Great vibe too and Frank, the owner, who we just mettonight is fantastic! Highly recommend! Read more