Reviews for La Nonna's Pizzeria in Huntington Station, NY

I don?t think I?ve ever written a bad review but this had to be done. Bought a regular pie and a grandma pie. Both tasted like... cardboard, grandma pie was extremely salty?not enough cheese on the regular pie (could see the sauce in some places). Thebuffalo wings were INEDIBLE. This place used to be good but guess they?re trying to cut costs by using garbage ingredients. Doyourself a favor and spend those extra few dollars on a good pizzeria. Won?t be returning here, that?s for sure. Read more

THE BEST PIZZA on Long Island! We always order the ultra thin white pie with spinach, its incredible! All of the pies are great,... and so are the salads. The staff at Porsche Huntington only orders from La Nonnas! Read more

This was dissppinting. I received inedible food. I thought I was ordering bite size pieces of chicken, but this looks like a... chicken roll. Burnt onto the tin foil and hard as a rock. Read more

I wish I could say this place is good. I downloaded their app, placed an order through said app for delivery, and got... confirmation emails. Over an hour later, nothing. Called them and they have no record. I read the confirmation numbers but didntmatter. Recommend going in person cause otherwise you will just be hungry and angry. I wouldnt bother with a review but donthave an app and blame someone for ordering from the wrong place. Read more

My 5 year old is in love with the regular cheese pizza. We ordered a pie during her girl scout sales event and ate outside... after. She ate almost 3 slices and have been dreaming of it since. My 3 year old loved the garlic knot with grilled chicken,tomato and mozzarella. The staff is wonderful and accommodating. Read more

Definitely worth a visit if you're in the Huntington area. Slices are authentic and not greasy. Staff amiable and very attentive... as well! Read more

Delicious Pizza reminiscent of Brooklyn! Excellent crust! Try their pepperoni pin wheels, deep fried calzone and other dishes,... they are great! This place offers more of a unique variety and twists on some old favorites. Read more

Great pizza for Suffolk county. Try the BBQ Chicken pizza. Easy to see right off of Jericho Turnpike servicing Northport, Dix... Hills and Commack New York. Reasonably priced. Plenty of parking and a wheel chair accessible entrance. Clean facilities. Nice friendly staff. We will definitely be going back. We just got our Valentine's Day Pizza. Amazing. Read more