Reviews for Matteo's of Huntington in Huntington Station, NY

We had our wedding rehearsal dinner here and we absolutely love this place!! The food is always amazing, the drinks and service... are great, and the restaurant itself is very nice! We worked with Dennis to secure the date for our rehearsal dinner and he wasgreat - very nice and the communication was easy! We did a family style dinner and the food was soo good - everyone kept ravingabout it. We did the silver package which was multiple courses, wine and beer, and was very affordable! You really get a lot foryour money. Would def recommend for events or date night!!! Read more

Food & service is very good. The dinner special (Mon - Thurs) offers value and portioned nicely. The one drawback; it is... terribly noisy when crowded and table conversations are difficult if not impossible. Room ambiance is lovely. Acoustics are not,a common problem.. Read more

I started with 4 stars cause I feel the host/ hostess sets the tone for the whole experience; and luckily my server, Rachel,... made it better for me to enjoy my drink and dinner. Party of one NEVER wants to be seated in the middle of the diningspace!! Very good food. The tiramisu was amazing ???? Read more

This used to be our families favorite restaurant. Ever since Covid hit ive had some bad meals. White clam sauce with sand in... it, overcooked veal, very bland chops, even the other night a steak that had zero flavor. Asked for steak sauce just to give itsomething and got an empty bottle of A-1 that was expired! Beautiful restaurant with pretty people but they need to hiresome decent cooks. Read more

Not enough parking, but the food is very good and the waitstaff is attentive without being overbearing. Nice inside, but it... gets quite loud and seems very bright. The food was very well prepared, quite tasty, and the portions are just right. We werethere for Restaurant Week. Read more

The food was amazing, from the appetizers, to the pasta, to the medium rare steak ( which was cooked to perfection).The service... was outstanding and the bathroom was immaculate. My only disappointment or complaint would be that the fresh fruit andcheesecake it was as if it was sitting in the fridge uncovered. Hence, it was stale and tasted of the fridge. Also drinks arepricey, although they tasted good and packed a puch. Be aware, this place is nt cheap but well worth it. Read more

Very nice restaurant - I live in the neighborhood so I've been here more than once. Staff is friendly & accommodating-- Mgr. was... making the rounds to assure customers were being taken care of. Only "drawback" is that it can get quite noisy when the placeis full. FYI I had the shrimp Ultimo-- delicious!!! Read more

I have past this place for years and always wanted to check it out. So yesterday I was excited when my buddy suggested... it. Unfortunately it didn't come close to meeting my expectations. The place was nicely decorated, had a cool bar and a greatbartender named John. My disappointment was in the food. The octopus and white beans had absolutely no flavor. It was cookedwell. Not chewy.....but there was nothing there taste wise. The same thing for the Veal Milanese. It definitely could haveused more flavor. I also didn't like the plating of this dish. They took the fried veal and put it at the bottom of the plate.So it was covered with salad, onions, tomatoes and cheese slices. The breaded Veal was totally soggy and flavorless. Theburrata, fried zucchini and salami and cheese plates were fine. John was a great guy, attentive bartender and helpful. He alsomade a very good expresso. It was a very expensive evening which came out to $200 each, which I wouldn't have minded if Iwould have enjoyed the food. However I didn't. Therefore I most likely won't return. Read more