Reviews for Colombo's Cafe & Pastries in Hyannis, MA
Once again a fabulous meal. The braised short ribs were done to perfection. My wife had the stuffed peppers. Said they were... better than hers and she's a terrific cook. Red our server was attentive without being overbearing. He recommended the carrotcake for dessert as being excellent and he was right. Always look forward to dining there when on the Cape. Read more
Normally we love their food, did DoorDash tonight because Tourists and traffic are crazy and we’ve had long weeks at work.... They should take the scallop and bacon pizza off the menu for DoorDash and probably reconsider the scallop they put on it for$22. I think they cut up 1 scallop into 6 pieces and put it on the pizza. Totally not worth the money. Received it cold and hardas a rock. Also for a restaurant of the caliber I’m surprised they didn’t put salt and pepper on the asparagus. Chargingpeople for this food and not putting salt and pepperoni is unbelievable. Locals at that. Not impressed. Read more
Went here for lunch with my boyfriend to end our cape weekend, food and drinks were great and our bartender Eric was so... attentive and entertaining, you could tell he enjoys working here and seemed to have a great rapport with regular customers, wehad the margarita pizza which had wonderful fresh tasting tomatoes, the clam chowder was amazing perfectly salty and creamy withthe oyster crackers. Eric even put together a wonderful cocktail for me when I saw they had elderflower liqueur, ask for thegreen goddess! I’ve had years down the cape with my family and have never had a disappointing meal here Read more
We had a nice dinner here. Our waitress was very good, and everyone enjoyed their food. I had the short rib ragu which tasted... great, but the pasta left a little to be desired. I think it was homemade pasta which is great, but it was not formed nicelyand it seemed like they had let it dry out some before recooking or something. It was like 1"wide noodles and several had stucktogether so it was not fully cooked. I still enjoyed the meal though and it was not worth a delay to send it back, butotherwise I would have given 5 stars. Read more
Awesome experience at the bar where Chris is the magician managing drinks for the whole restaurant guests over 100 tables... perhaps. Food is just fantastic and served piping hot just the way we love it. Our first five star meal in Cape Cod. Till nowit was 0-2 so This place redeemed it all. Fantastic muscles and shrimp Diavolo. Sangria was just fabulous. Thanks Chris. Read more
The food was so delicious I could cry omg it was my birthday and my they made sure I enjoyed my time my server was karen shes a... jamaican go ask for her guys ??? Read more
Absolutely amazing food!! Told us wait would be an hour, 15 minutes later they called us back and said they could seat us!! I... enjoyed the Buratta Linguini incredibly and I loved the turtle cheesecake. The street music was FANTASTIC, there was a birthdayin our party and our waiter went over and requested songs for us!! Our waitress was fantastic, they were incredibly busy andthey were able to keep up and check on us. Not to mention the amazing cars they have?? Wow!! There is a reason it’s so busy,this Italian place is not to be missed!! Thank you Colombo’s!! Read more
We came to celebrate our 4 year wedding anniversary. The service was excellent. We shared the Mussels appetizer. My husband... had the Chicken and Alfredo. I had the Colombo A LA Paella with Shrimp, Mussels, Scallops, Chicken and a 1 lb Lobsteradded. For dessert he had the New York Cheesecake with Raspberry Sauce, and I had the Carrot Cake. We can't wait to come back. Read more