Reviews for Lucy's New York Style Pizza in Idaho Falls, ID
Visiting in from Utah and came across the little gem. We ordered the three different kinds of bread and they all were great... specially the cheese sticks. Also ordered the caprese salad and it was really good! Plus the slice of Roni pizza. Definitely agood little pizza joint! Read more
This is my first time eating pizza here and I was from out of town and I'm going to tell you you have some of the best pizza... I've ever tasted. There's plenty of choices the slices are huge like New York slices. You can't go away hungry at this place.It's a little bit on the higher price for what you're getting but it's probably worth it. I love that you can write on the tablewith dry erase markers that really entertains children if you bring kids. I actually ate here twice while I was in town becauseit's one of my kids' favorite places. Read more
Best pizza in Idaho Falls, full stop. It's as close to true New York style that you'll get this side of New York. I rarely... venture far into their menu because the pizza is just so good. It's all about their hands tossed crust and wood fired oven thatmakes it so good. And I'm not sure how they've managed to keep such good, friendly, competent staff when everybody else seems tobe struggling so much in that department, but even through COVID and shutdowns and everything they've always shined in thatdepartment. That plus the 2 slice lunch special will keep me coming back very regularly. Read more
The wings here are fantastic, one of the best Buffalo sauces I?ve had in a long time. The pizza was good, I do wish it was a... little more crisp, but I will be coming back. Read more
If your tongue wants to savor the flavor of pure awesomeness - then Lucy's has you covered! The Zestpian was like a magical... spicy unicorn prancing on my tongue singing, "Zesty!!". Their gluten free crust is good and their gluten free brownies are evenbetter! Imagine a sweet, gooey, little chocolate square of perfection making your every gluten wish come true - except there isno gluten! It's perfection! Can't wait to return here! The staff was amazing too! Our family kept spilling drinks (this neverhappens!) And she was so friendly about It! Amazing waitress! Give her a raise or the very least, some free gooey chocolatesquares of love! Read more
The pizza is good here. Cute place to go on a date without overspending. We gave it 1 star for environment , another for value... (great prices) and 3 for service. Read more
This is such a great pizza place! New York style pizza and the slices are huge. It's very affordable and the staff are great. We... showed up during the after lunch time and they even gave us complimentary pickles and olives. One pizza was enough for 5 adultsand 2 children as well as some cheese sticks. If you are in the Idaho falls area or even Orem UT get a pizza here!! Read more
The atmosphere and food was great. But I was with another person and we both ordered the salad with a slice. I was somehow... charged $2 more. The waitress didn't catch the mistake at checkout and when I asked about it, she just kind of stared at me. Iwas in a rush so I just let it go. Then about 2 hours later there was a rumble in my stomach. I ended up having an eventfultrip to the lavatory. I asked the person I went with if that food had traveled straight through him as well. He confirmed thatit did, unfortunately. Read more