Reviews for Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs in Idaho Falls, ID
My wife and I had a coupon that if we buy one half sandwich (6?) and two medium drinks, we get one half sandwich free. The... coupon also had a limit if $6 discount. What is bizarre is that there isn?t a single half sandwich on the menu less than $6.89.Very strange wording: one 6? sandwich free up to $6. My wife and I are not normally one to buy drinks, so in the end it wouldhave been cheaper for us to buy one full length sandwich and split it. So if you typically buy drinks, it was a good deal. But amedium drink is $2.69 each. It did come with a bag of chips which we weren?t expecting and that was nice. The bag is about thesize of a normal 1oz bag of chips but it had half the amount of chips. So probably a 1/2 oz bag (haha I can?t remember what itsaid on the bag). I bought the Italian combo and while the sandwich does not look like what I would have expected, I waspleasantly surprised at how good it tasted. And the staff were very friendly. Overall our experience was good. We just spentmore than we thought we would have with the coupon we had. Read more
My son and I decided we wanted sandwiches on our little mother/son dinner out. The staff was so friendly and helpful! I got the... Southwest Chipotle Steak and it was so good! I ate 3/4 of a whole sandwich! My son got a half ham and cheese and he ate thewhole thing. We shared an order of their spicy fries too. Their fry sauce is one of the main reasons I love this place! Prettysure it?s made with bbq sauce instead of ketchup like most places so it has that sweetness with a tiny kick! Read more
How have I never left a review for papa Kelsey?s. Back in high school I used to go once a week or more and that?s been 20 years.... I like the pizza sun, turkey and cheese, spicy fries and their pizza. All the breads are made in house. The pizza gets thetoppings under the cheese and the spicy fry comes with a fry sauce uniquely made with bbq sauce. Just go eat there. Read more
Not impressed at all! My husband ordered the Italian or something like that but I didn?t eat anything cause it wasn?t a clean... place! The sausage is very good and my husband did enjoy his sandwich?thank goodness! Several tables were in need of beingcleaned off and they weren?t busy? we were the only ones in the restaurant? and yes the two employees were too lazy to clean offfive tables! The menu is decent size and the pizzas did look amazing in the pictures! Read more
I ordered a sandwich and a breakfast burrito... all I recieved was stale/burnt breaksticks. Please tell me how this happens? Or... why it is acceptable? Read more
Yikes. In case the pictures don't speak for themselves, this was supposed to the "wrangler" sandwich with "Steak, Mushrooms,... Onions, BBQ Sauce, Pineapple & Melted Cheese." No cheese, or sauce, which hardly matters, since it was, in our opinion, notedible. We immediately threw the half-empty "soup" away. It was supposedly "potato." There were no potatoes. It was like someoneadded a lot of milk to a can of store brand potato chowder. Since we ordered at the end of the night, I suspect that we wound upwith whatever was left in the pot. Now, I know what you're thinking: At the least the pizza is good, right? I apparentlyneglected to take a picture of ours, but it was like revisiting the high school cafeteria. I mean, we ate it because we paid forit and we were hungry, but it wasn't particularly good. The soup and sandwich went into the trash. :-( Read more
I really had high expectations for this place from everyone that told me how good it is, I got a chef salad and its basically... ham, turkey and cheese where is the avocado or cucumbers? Salad was so watery I could have had a drink after, the fries weremush but had a good flavor, the salad was not worth 7 dollars!! Not a great first impression. Read more
This place never disappoints! The Turkey supreme is my all-time favorite, but everything I have had is so delicious!