Reviews for Idyllwild Pizza Company in Idyllwild-Pine Cove, CA

Local pizza spot with beer and an arcade. Came here for lunch at 11:30am (right when they opened) and there was a short line... already. Indoor and outdoor tables are available. Credit cards accepted but there?s a $5 minimum. We had a large TahquitzSupreme pizza to share among four people and that was a good portion for everyone to get 2-3 slices each. They have salads andsandwiches for those who don?t want a heavy meal. This is good for large groups and for children. They have high chairsavailable. Water is self-service. There are restrooms behind the bar. You order at the counter and then they?ll call your nameonce the food is ready. Read more

I've been coming to Idyllwild Pizza Company for 25 years, and I've seen it change a lot in that time. It's still good, maybe not... exactly the same as it once was, but it's still definitely worth going. The pizza is good, the sandwiches are good, the beverageselection is good, and the service is friendly and efficient. Hard to go wrong. Read more

Being a Pizza Lover. I can be pretty judgmental when it comes to pizza. Having moved here from Wisconsin, it was such an amazing... treat to eat their pizza. Takes just a like a pizza joint back home. The crust is really good and the sauce is almost perfect inmy humble opinion. So not only do I come here regularly for the pizza, but also a trip back home as well. Thanks guys keep upthe amazing work. Read more

So very good? the dough is fresh and taste amazing as well as the cheese. If you loved home made pizza stop by and have it here.

Pizza is amazing!!! The wings on the other hand had a rubbery consistency and were like NUCLEAR to the touch which makes me... think they were microwaved. Other than that literally everything else is amazing. Read more

We ordered a large pepperoni pizza to go. The pizza was large enough for four people plus we had leftovers. It took 20 minutes... to prepare. While we waited we had some beers. Pretty nice beer selection. They had several large TVs and an arcade gameroom. The only negative was the place wasn't as clean as it could be. I would definitely eat here again. Read more

Overall: B+ Layout & decor: ?????????? Food quality: ?????????? Cleanliness: ?????????? Customer service: ?????????? Timeliness:... ?????????? Bathroom: ?????? Review: overall, everything was good, everything is timely, no issues here. I got the chickengourmet pizza & it was pretty tasty. Would definitely come back here again. Read more

I forgot to take a picture of the pizza, but their pizza is amazing! I don't remember this last time or if they had a different... chef during covid time, but this time it was even better. The crust tasted like a salted pretzel. It was so delicious! Inregards to their bathroom, we wished there was at least a couple stalls for the women's restroom. The restaurant was busy(which was around when we went), the bathroom was not available for a long time with just 1 stall. Other than that, deliciouspizza! Read more