Reviews for ATHENS ON 86th in Indianapolis, IN
We were probably the last table for the night tonight (11/11), but the service was still absolutely amazing. Thank you, George... (I hope I've spelled your name right), for helping make our anniversary special! Read more
Nice ambiance, the bread that came out in the beginning was ???? Everything else was okay and pricier than expected.
First time here!! We were one of the first few people in for lunch today..Was immediately greeted by the owner who was beautiful... and extremely friendly she even came out and opened the door and welcomed us in, Erica took care of us and because we were oneof the only tables filled she talked to us a bit which was also so welcoming and made us feel comfortable! She helped menavigate the menu because I was torn between a couple of things! I got the chicken kebob lunch which came with a side salad andtoast the salad was very good maybe a little over dressed but I?d just ask for the dressing on the side next time..all thevegetables were very fresh tasting and crunchy! The toast was very basic maybe season it with green spices and garlic that wouldbe a really nice touch! The kabob was great flavor all the way through chicken was a little dry, and the onions still had theskins on it..the rice was very basic and I didn?t care for it I took only one bite?HOWEVER! The Greek potatoes Oh My God! Thosewere AMAZING! And I?m not a big potato fan..I?d come back for those alone! Now that we covered the food.. The ambience of therestaurant was AMAZING you really feel like you are transported to Greece! So so beautiful I had to get a picture! Read more
Where to even start. Walking in the doors your greeted by a friendly face. The service was outtanding!! The food was out of this... word. Everything is so fresh and has SO much flavor. I love that it is a local establishment. Seriously do not skip this place!Even if you haven?t had Greek food, try something new ( like we did tonight)! Keyti you were an amazing server! Thanks for allthe great recommendations. Read more
I had the Athenian grilled chicken sandwich and fries. It was so good!! Had the baklava for desert which was also ????! The... waitress was so nice and attentive. I will be back again! Read more
Arrived about 7PM on a Saturday evening and almost wasn't seated without a reservation, which they recommended for the weekend.... Service and food were good although my shrimp kabobs weren't hot. Pitted olives would be preferable in the salad. Read more
The manager Erica really makes this place feel special and with best Greek food in town it is a must.
I?m so glad I found this place! What a hidden gem! Fine dining atmosphere, attentive servers, and friendly staff. Food was... phenomenal - best Greek I have had in a long time. Gyro meat cooked to perfect. Truly fresh fries. Taziki sauce excellent. Pitawas perfect. Flaming cheese was perfect. I will definitely be back! Thanks for a great experience! Read more