Reviews for Caplinger's Fresh Catch in Indianapolis, IN

Love their sandwich. You can ask them to make any sandwich with their fish or shrimp, fried or grilled.

Stopped here for lunch on a road trip at 11:45am on a Tuesday. Ordered the Caplinger?s Special fried fish sandwich with all the... fixings, calamari fries, and sides of green beans and Cajun slaw. Came out pretty quickly (5-10 min) and tasted hot and fresh.The green beans were just okay but everything else was great! Read more

First time going there. I got catfish dinner it was delicious mac cheese, canned yams.. Also purchased Cajun crab dip .

Caplinger Fresh Catch is a fresh fish market; they also sell cooked dinners, sandwiches and seasonings. They are located near... Starbucks a meal costs between 14-,25 dollars My scores: cleanliness 5, service 5, food 5. I highly recommend checking thisrestaurant out for fish or seafood Read more

Came here for lunch after the recommendation of a coworker. Fish was fresh and the staff was friendly. The fish had a little too... much pepper and lemon for my taste but was still good. If you like seafood I do recommend this restaurant/store for a quicklunch. Read more

My first visit to Caplingers today 5/14. I ordered alligator bites and salmon dinner. Both meals were delicious! My first time... trying alligator and it amazing! The wait was about 45 min, we ordered there. I also got a oreo cheesecake which was reallygood. The sides are really small, I ordered hushpuppies and green beans both were soulful ???? Read more

We have enjoyed eating Caplingers at least once a month for the last few years. We absolutely love their cod dinner. Tonight's... dinner was highly disappointing however. The pieces of fish were very small, barely half the size they usually are. My husbandinquired, but they wouldn't compensate. Paid about $30 for one meal and an extra crab cake. Feeling a little ripped off. Read more

This was my first time here. I had never heard of this place. I am a seafood lover so I had to come check it out. I had the... whiting dinner. I was surprised to be served with two little thin pieces of fish. The fish was seasoned great. The first piecewas good but the second piece hardly had any meat. It tasted like batter fried hard. The Mac and cheese was okay but it was toomuch Velveeta(thats what it tasted like) for my liking. The red beans and rice could have been spicier. The greens were thestar of the show. They were seasoned perfectly. I really enjoyed the hush puppies, I eat then again!! Read more