Reviews for Prodigy Burger Bar in Indianapolis, IN

First time experience eating at the prodigy, and the food is fairly priced, was worth every dollar spent. The fried green... tomatoes was well worth eating, and the no name burger was very filling. The hubby had fun with the shapes of the onion rings.. Read more

As soon as I walked in I was greeted by Michael P. the server for the bar. (I sat at the bar) He was super friendly, personable,... funny and an overall joy!! Great segue into some great food! My food came out hot and fresh! The Fried Green Tomatoes & thesauce that comes with it are a must try!???????? I'm not a patty melt type of person but the Prodigy Melt was pretty good! Thefries are good with whatever season they dusted on them! They have some great menu items and I can't wait to get back and trythem!! Read more

Mochtails are delicious! Loved the burgers and the nachos. Great service as well. They even washed our toddlers plate we brought... in with us! We'll be back. Read more

I absolutely love the burgers and fries here !! I always build my burger. This time I got the single patty mushroom and pepper... Jack cheese on a pretzel bun with salt and vinegar fries. The fries do not have a strong vinegar vibe..they are seasoned justperfectly and the cheese sauce is pretty decent. Also the chilli is good it's more of a sauce you might put on fries or hotdogsnot a dish on its own. I was a bit disappointed in the Greenwood location because the service isnt near as friendly as the w.10th st. Location. Still not bad service..just a little "dry". Still, we will return but probably to the w. 10th st. Location:). Read more

Beyond Burgers here are amazing, I recommend the mushroom Swiss or if you like it spicy, the reaper. The regular fries are... better than truffle. Come check it out, great menu! Read more

We went for the first time yesterday after hearing a lot of good things. The food was really good, the smash burgers are... awesome, little messy but worth it. We had pretzel nuggets (a substitute for the fries) also great. Our server was also good,really attentiive and on top of her game. We definitely will be back. Read more

They have a staffing issue, but we got our drinks and food pretty quickly considering the circumstances. The meals are... expensive: $15 for a small burger and fries. Burger was slightly dry, but tasty. Read more

The better half and I decided to try Prodigy Burger Bar for the first time! Needless to say, I was very impressed with my... turkey burger and side salad! I ordered a turkey burger on a lettuce bun, with bacon, American and Gouda cheese, lettuce,tomatoes, pickle, red onion, sautéed onions, mayo, ketchup, mustard and avocado! It was delicious!! I ordered it with a sidesalad and the apple vinagrette dressing, loved that it was a real salad and that no iceberg lettuce was involved!! I snuck someof hubby's fries and they were yummy too, a sweet/salty combination, cooked perfectly. If you haven't been, I highly recommendit. As well as everywhere else right now, they seem to be having trouble with staffing so come with some time to have a drinkand enjoy your time there - or maybe if your looking for employment...???????????? Read more