Reviews for St. Elmo Steak House in Indianapolis, IN
The food and service was excellent. The shrimp cocktail was the best my father has ever had and lived up to the hype. The steaks... were tender and seasoned to perfection. I highly recommend the 38 oz prime rib and the Tomahawk. All of our steaks wereexquisite and and the blacking seasoning really put them over the top. The onion rings and mashed potatoes were excellent aswell. The Bourbon butter cake and Green Apple sorbet were a perfect end to our meal. Mark our waiter was personable and veryattentive. I would highly recommend this establishment to anyone in the Indianapolis area and to anyone from all over as it isdefinitely worth the drive. Read more
Ok, for a visit to the past this is a restaurant you must visit. It is high end but the place was awesome. We sat at the bar... because we didn't have a reservation but lost nothing in the experience. Chuck took care of us. The drinks were mixed perfectly.The steaks were huge and delicious. The service was super fast for being so busy. The nostalgia of the place was great. Theplace was beautiful. The woodwork was so extravagant and beautiful. The pictures on the wall from Indianapolis were great tolook at. And to top it off. The double chocolate mousse was absolutely to die for. Read more
Had a fabulous dinner last night at St. Elmo Steakhouse! It was my second visit there and naturally got the shrimp cocktail and... it was the best shrimp cocktail I've ever had! The shrimp is large and the cocktail sauce is delicious! Be warned it will clearyour sinuses though, but so good! A must experience. I had the New York Strip and it was delectable! The service was amazing aswell! Our waiter was very personable and met all of our table's needs. Highly recommend! Read more
Great meal, great service, and a charming old school atmosphere. It really doesn't get more classic than this place. The... signature cocktail sauce will really punch you in the mouth, but it is delicious. The steak was tender, and delicious.Definitely go for the Bourbon Butter Cake if it's on the menu! Read more
I have to start by saying the food was awesome. I was recommended by several people. The best Caesar salad i have ever had. The... steak, perfect and the dessert oh my god they were good. But more importantly, our server Sara was absolutely incredible. Ofcourse ill be back for the food but ill also be going back because of Sara. She was friendly, knowledgeable, fun an all aroundgreat person. I will have to call ahead to make sure she is working. Read more
St. Elmo Steak House has a wonderful atmosphere. There are multiple floors so being seated can be a trek, but not unpleasant.... The prices are steep for the average consumer, but the portions and flavor are well worth the price tag. I was pleasantlysurprised and their food AND drinks far exceeded my expectations. Read more
Coming from someone on a keto diet, this was a great place to eat. My steak was delicious, although pretty fatty. We also got... brussel sprouts (which were fantastic) and green beans, too. I had some lobster bisque that was quite good, but we didn't trythe shrimp that everyone said they're known for. The ambiance was nice and our waitress was very good, but I personally feellike we could have gotten a comparable meal for half the price at another steakhouse. Overall, it was a good experience (for onetime to say we'd been there) but I don't think it was worth as much money as we paid. Read more
Everything was delicious! Tied for first place as the best steak I've ever had. I had the filet, and my husband had a 38 oz... prime rib. Both cooked to perfection! Our server, Ricardo, was AMAZING! Navy bean soup was awesome! If you get dessert, make itthe butter cake...you will not be disappointed! I would definitely dine here again! Read more