Reviews for Sully's Grill at Sullivan Hardware & Garden in Indianapolis, IN

Small, but creative and outstanding menu. Who would have thought that eating at the hardware store would be a thing? And a... really good thing, at that! There are always choices for meat eaters, vegetarians and vegans. I have been here at least 6 timesin the past month - four times for lunch and twice for dinner. The menu is the same for each meal, but there are specials eachday that are not on the menu. Desserts are also incredible. The menu changes seasonally, so I don't want to mention specificitems in case they are not available when you go. All I can say is that I've had multiple appetizers, salads and sandwiches andI have only eaten one thing that I felt was NOT outstanding. It was merely really good. Some may find it pricey, but for thefreshness of the ingredients and the creative preparation, I happen to think it's a great deal. You can buy similar foodelsewhere for less money, but it's not going to be made with this level of expertise and quality. Read more

10/10 experience. What a hidden GEM! Delicious food, friendly staff, and super kind and accommodating for food allergies. Might... become my favorite after church brunch spot. Can?t wait to go back! Read more

It was very good. Very convenient to shop, eat, and shop some more. The server was helpful and did a good job. We sat outside... and enjoyed it very much. Read more

Have you experienced Sully's Grill within Sullivan's Do It Best Hardware on N Keystone Ave? Their food is amazing and the... upscale Beef Brisket Sandwich is one of the best you'll ever eat! Read more

Great food. Friendly and attentive staff. Quality beer and wine selections. The couscous brisket soup "to die for."

The plan was breakfast after church but we got there a little too late. We decide to stay and have lunch. The food was... absolutely amazing. It was so flavorful. Our waitress was great. Never thought a restaurant would be locate in a hardware andgarden shop. Get your flower fix then eat a great meal. Read more

Great place for a fabulous lunch! Great service and excellent food. Will definitely be going back! I had the citrus spinach... salad and it was wonderful. Read more

Our second time at Sully's. Once again it is everything the name implies! Pat Sullivan is an extraordinary business man. The... little bistro inside of 71st and Keystone is a gem. From the special wine to the special of the day ( smoked turkey w brie andapple chutney ) to the fresh spinach and arugula salad to the Parmigian butternut squash soup the meal was superb!! Our waitress[ Victoria ] was superb with her customer service and suggestions to enhance our dining experience!! I suggest you ask for herwhen you arrive. Read more