Reviews for The Juicy Seafood Restaurant & Bar- Castleton in Indianapolis, IN

I came about a year ago and had a great time so we decided to do it again this year for my sister's birthday. She had a great... time the service was on point and most importantly the food was good. Just a heads up it's a little pricey but if you cool withthat then you should be good. Read more

I love that Indy has a place where you can go and get seafood boil! The quality of seafood was amazing and the sauces were very... delicious. They offer very fair special combos. I was wanting to get the Red Bomb but decided to get the Black and Red Bomb forTwo to share with my brother because it was only an extra $7 for lobster tail! Can?t beat that! The server (David) was very niceas well and I?ve had him as a serve at otherJuicy locations as well! He is works the bar and serves tables, very nice and alwaysprofessional! Read more

The Snow Crab legs were SO good, and the shrimp were the bomb. So were the potatoes and sausage. We got the hot sauce on the... side and it was GREAT. 10/10 would eat again. Read more

Very good food. I ordered pick 2 combo which had 2 fried catfish and 2 chicken tenders with Cajun fries. Well seasoned and was... steaming hot. I will definitely return and try out the crab/lobster boils next time Read more

Nice place to hangout and eat spicy juicy seafood ( snow crab, fish, claw fish, mussels, crawfish, lobster, shrimp and many... )with a side of options ( rice ). Must try the Red bomb and juicy spicy option from the menu. Don?t miss it. Come and enjoy thebag of mixed seafood combo with sea creatures ???? fried appetizers. Read more

Amazing food, amazing service. Only had to wait 30 minutes for a table for 3 on a Saturday evening. Our server was so friendly,... helpful, prompt and perfect. Best seafood hands down. Chicken basket and fries for kids is a sure won as well! Read more

Delicious!! This is some of the best seafood I've ever had! It comes out in this big bag that it was steamed in. You pick your... seasoning between garlic butter, lemon pepper, cajun, or a miture of all. We started out with an appetuzer of calamari. It cameout with a sweet chili sauce to dip it in. We had never tried that before, everywhere we have had it has always come withmarinara sauce...let me tell you, that sweet chili sauce was a game changer....it was AMAZING on there!! It was also amazingdipping our shrimp and crab in too! (Who would have guessed that?!?!) It was not spicy either. I got the lobster tail, crableggs, shrimp, corn, and potatoes. For $36.99. My fiancee got the build your own and he got Dungeness crab and shrimp with cornand potatoes for I think $33.99. We both got the mixture of seasoning. We are from out of state, this will definitely be wherewe eat at again when we are in the area or passing through again! Read more

5 Stars Hands Down!!! Huge Shoutout to our waitress Lee! She was very professional, down to earth and extremely easy to work... with! She was able to give us tips on what to order based on our cravings and she checked on us periodically without being ahelicopter waitress! Our food was extremely fresh and good! We ordered the Mr. Captain?s Special which included: -1 Cluster ofCrab Legs -1/2 lb of shrimp -Sausage -Corn -2 Eggs -2 Potatoes With your choice of sauce! We also ordered the Spicy Catfishwith Cajun Fries which we received 4 pieces of Fish! The breading on the fish was crispy & crunchy as well! We were seatedextremely quick and the Water was actually good! Great Job Juicy! Great Job Lee! Read more