Reviews for Stone Oven Pizzeria - The Whistle Stop in Islamorada, FL

The ingredients were amazing! The cheese stretched so far.. Best pizza I've had in a LONG time. Waitress was really nice too.

Ordered 2 small pizzas and garlic knots, both were amazing! I highly suggest the chicken bacon ranch pizza!

Some of the best pizza you’ll ever have anywhere in the upper Florida Keys. Hot, fresh, cheesy, and delicious. You won’t be... disappointed Read more

Food and service were exceptional! One of the best meals we had while on vacation. Pizza and mozzarella sticks were cooked to... perfection. Great place that I’d recommend to others. Read more

The pizza here was excellent. It came out hot and could speak the sauce was very good and tasted homemade the homemade. We... weren't that hungry when we went in but it smelled so good that we definitely ordered way too much. If you're looking for greatpizza in the Key Largo area,this is the place to go. Read more

Best pizza on the Island. I have lived here for 20 years and within the last few have really struggled to find a decent pizza... place with crust that was not to thick and came out crispy…. This is our go to place for pizza night! Read more

Pizza was overcooked and bad in many ways. I think it had too much seasoning. At first it was good then makes you feel sick.... The chicken was cooked so much that it was almost brittle. Even the garlic knots were bad. Like gnawing on leather. I washungry so I had a couple slices and this was the worst decision all day. Lastly, we stopped by to check the place out on ourway through before we ordered. There is a large sign saying they deliver, but when I called they said they don't. Read more

This pizzeria had the best reviews so we thought why not! We ordered garlic knots and supreme large pizza & it was Y U M M Y.... The cheese was even delicious and I’m not a huge cheese eater. (I prefer not cheesy lol). The young gentleman that was cookingthe pizza did an awesome job. The woman who was are server was killing it even though they got slammed. I want to give them around of a applause for getting the orders in and out in a timely manner and not forgetting about us. If you’re looking forsome good pizza & beer this is your place! Read more