Reviews for Collegetown Bagels in Ithaca, NY
Glad Collegetown Bagels is still around! They were smaller and on the other side of College Ave when 30+ years ago. When I was... just there last Sunday, sandwiches were taking 25 minutes - worth the wait, I'm sure. We opted for toasted bagels with creamcheese, which took only five minutes. The Irish Cream latte was very sweet. The Butter Pecan Cocoa was delicious. The drinkstook ten minutes. And the Smores bar was heavenly! Read more
Delicious bagels. The bagel menu is extensive so i took a while to decide. The smooth menu was also big. You can customize the... smoothie with whatever fruits you want. However, the smoothie was ok. A bit bland. I'd go for the famous, classic bagels. Read more
Have been to the area few times, but first visit to Collegetown Bagels, I must say it?s much more than the name says. Lots of... varieties, food & beverages are tasty and fresh, service is friendly and efficient. Would recommend you to make a trip here,before considering any other ones. Just minutes away from anywhere in Cornell area. Thank you and keep up with the good job. Read more
DELISH!!! I loved the vibe, coffee, bagels and variety. I had to stop myself from visiting a third time before heading back to... the Mitten state. Also love that they stock baked goods from Ithaca Bakery, one place to grab goodies from both local gems. I'mwith it! Read more
Absolutely the best bagel ???? shop hands down ? I grew up in Brooklyn and I know good bagels? take it from me this place is... worth the stop and the staff? super friendly. Read more
Iconic college town sandwich shop! I got Mexican bagel on sesame bagel with 6 strips of bacon?yum, yum. And a large hot late.
Great place for coffee, snacks, sweets and excellent vibe to enjoy the weather. Loved the bagel especially the egg/Pesto one... with the coffee. Read more
After I got my coffee, I looked for the table where most coffee shops put the milk. Unfortunately, I could not find the milk, so... I asked the staff for either H&H or whole milk. The staff replied, "so you want a latte, which will cost extra dollars.? Hercomment shocked me because the other coffee shops never asked me for extra money for milk. The setting and food were great. Butgood luck to the next person who asks for milk. Read more