Reviews for Collegetown Bagels in Ithaca, NY
Great place for sandwiches and bagels! Sandwiches are good! Also they have good breakfast sandwiches! Coffee was great. Indoor... and outdoor seating. Great atmosphere inside. Big selection of sweets and pastries. Read more
I don't write reviews often however this place deserves one. If you want a quality breakfast in Ithaca, especially downtown,... this is the place. The service was excellent and the food was very nice. Their coffee is very good as well as their smoothies.The bagels were nice and warm and the ingredients were fresh. All around, great little joint. Read more
Super cute spot with fun decor and lovely outdoor seating. Had the Liz Lemonade and The Roundhouse breakfast bagel.
It was a wait for our order (sandwich and coffee ordered separately, which TBH didn't make much sense to me...) BUT it was well... worth it. I recommend the Rise 'N Grind...so good. I would've added a photo but it was already gone. My wife got Ryan's Favorite(pictured). We both got mochaccinos too. Read more
I used to live in Ithaca, born there. I had been thinking about a bagel from Collegtown Bagels my whole trip....but...after... paying $12 plus for 3 bagels...ALL three were so hard and stale we couldn't even eat them. Servers were great though. I miss theold days where they were made fresh every morning... Read more
I?m coming from New York City which some say is famous for a little doughy ball of heaven known as the bagel, and I?d gladly eat... these bagels and sandwiches any day of the week. Try the Lindsey for a great sandwich, and I recommend the chocolate coveredcheesecake bar. Read more
The hype about this place is worth it. Everything is super efficient while still being very welcoming and casual. Huge amount of... options for food, as well as a variety of coffee, beer, and wine. I've never tried something bad. Read more
10 outta 10 you should get breakfast here. Best breakfast sandwich I?ve had in a long time. It?s laid back and in the heart of... Ithaca. Do yourself a favor and go. Read more