Reviews for Northstar Public House in Ithaca, NY
North Star was pretty good I had the Garlic Burger and it was very garlicky in a good way. Although I was a little disappointed... from looking at Google they had all these pics of some crazy dishes, Chicken and donuts, a waffle sandwich, some breakfast stuffthat looked amazing as well. Craziest thing on this menu was Salmon.... That might have been pre-covid because they are alsonot open for Brunch. Don't get me wrong the burger was good, the server said the menu stays relatively the same but theysometimes change things and the online website menu might not always be correct. On my quest to find the best and craziest foodthe server mentioned that they have the most amazing desserts (not on the menu or on the website menu) and that they areconstantly changing. Sadly after eating a whole dinner I was too full to eat anything, if I go back next time I'll have to getthe dessert menu first. Read more
I basically bumbled my way into this place and I am so glad I did - excellent! Ate on the covered patio, weather was perfect,... the ambience was great, the food was wonderful ... everything I like, and I need to be gluten-free - didn't know they cater tothat .. and dessert was beyond spectacular, as was the salad, salmon and wine! Read more
So they are good, yes. The demand they receive results in higher wait times than at other places I like around here. Seriously,... only come here if you have extra time to spend. Ye can walk around the 'hood while waiting & there is a pretty fine creeknearby. Read more
What a hidden gem! I took my entire family there for a recent celebration, without ever being there before or even seeing the... menu. (This is quite abnormal for me) Our party of 7 were easily seated. Mask mandates and vacc proof made us feel safe. Thetables, the glasses the water and the cloth napkins all made us feel much higher class than most restaurants on the commons butwith half the pretention. There were only good comfy vibes. The waitress was phenomenal, got so the orders right, checked infrequently, refilled drinks and was a joy to interact with! (I regret I didn't ask her name but she wore a bone with a colorfultie around it). The food was delicious and perfectly portioned. 10/10 will absolutely go again Read more
I went to Northstar with a group of friends, and we adored the outdoor seating. The restaurant has a cozy atmosphere with signs... making operation smooth. We had waited over an hour to get our food, which was probably the only bad thing about this place.When we did get the food, it looked delicious and tasted scrumptious. Would go again. Read more
While visiting Ithaca for a music festival, we happened upon this place accidentally while looking for parking. We decided to... get brunch here the next morning! It has a cozy local vibe, mixed with a contemporary and rustic touches. The food wasoutstanding and they serve food primarily sourced from the area. The menu was concise. Overall great find!!!! Read more
Mother's Day brunch was a great time. Everybody enjoyed their food and the service was great. The Fried Chicken and Donuts were... phenomenal and the French Toast is awesome! I want to come back sometime for dinner. Read more
Eclectic comfort food menu with interesting farm to table ingredients. Indoor and outdoor seating. Friendly, attentive servers.... Cherry sour cocktail was great. Casual venue was OK but bland. Definitely would go again for very good food at reasonable price. Read more