Reviews for The Boatyard Grill in Ithaca, NY
Superior staff. Service was top notch, quick and friendly. Lowell was our bartender and he was amazing. The other gentleman was... great as well. The onion soup and clam chowder were delicious. Drinks were delicious too. Dinner was presented well, but a bitbland for our liking. Read more
I never have a bad meal here. I live out in Aurora, so we will take the boat down the lake to have dinner here. Definitely... suggest to call ahead and make a reservation on the weekends, this place is always packed full and busy. The food is amazingand not one bad item can be listed. Some items are pricey the taste of meal beats any price listed next to it. Dessert is alsoamazing and flavorful! Make sure to save room for a lava cake or sizzling cookie! Read more
After a long 1h and 10 minutes wait to be seated on a Wednesday afternoon, we enjoy the magnificent Boatyard Grill. Our server... was Mark, really nice waiter, attentive and professional. Food was excellent, atmosphere very enjoyable ! I will not give 5starts do to the long wait, beside that it was an excellent evening ! Read more
I had an excellent meal here at one of the nicer spots in Ithaca. All the food, including the scallops and fries, were well... made. Great atmosphere. I’d come back. Read more
This may be long but it’ll be worth it! It’s Mother’s Day. My family is hundreds of miles away because I suddenly had to... work out of state. I’m here ALONE, on Mothers Day missing my family. They close for the night soon. My dinner is ABSOLUTEPERFECTION! I had the Parmesan Crusted Salmon (from their wood fired grill) which was lightly kissed by a delicious VodkaSauce, accompanied by perfectly prepared Jasmine Rice, and a Mixed Greens salad with a White Wine Cream Dressing. Extra pointsfor all foods on my plate being the appropriate temperature! Cool salad, hot fish and rice and sauce! Right temp, righttextures, great flavors!!!?! This place made my sort of sad Mother’s Day end very well indeed! Oh and my server Ashley wasfantastic as well! Hmmm do they serve breakfast?! Lol! Read more
Excellent service for sure including the waiter and the bartender. Also, “the dirty bird” drink is highly recommended. The... appetizers were a lot bigger than I thought (larger than most places) so I really appreciated that. They also make all the mealslook extremely nice. Great experience. Read more
Our visit to the Finger Lakes area was enhanced with our dinner at the Boatyard. Dined on the patio which was closed due to the... rain. But it was as outside as we could get. Had a wonderful bourbon smash, crispy calamari with fantastic sauces, grilledsalmon, and a Maker’s Mark sirloin. All choices were outstanding and delicious. Bethany was our very helpful server. Perfectsetting if we only had nice weather. We’ll be back. Read more
We had our friend reunion here and didn’t realise how popular this place is, especially on the weekend. They don’t take... reservations so at best, you can call early and be asked to put on the waiting list. We waited an hour and finally got a table.The food was delicious, although some of the steaks we a bit overcooked. They menu has a variety of options so you’lldefinitely find something you’ll like. Read more