Reviews for Lenny's Pizza & Bistro (AKA Lenny's of Jamesport) in Jamesport, NY

What a surprising little place to grab a drink and solid meal. The bistro has a small bar, excellent caring and attentive... staff, and the chicken marcella was delicious. Read more

Totally mistreated my wife while she was there with her nieces and nephews and others, then tried lying to me by saying they... were busy when pictures from my wife?s phone was the complete opposite. I can only speculate why ?certain? people are treated acertain way in certain places, but that?s up for debate. Thankfully I wasn?t there, as I am not as nice and my money is just asgood and probably better than anyone else who patrons there, especially from Suffolk County. Never go there again. Read more

This place is "Old School" and I mean that in a good way. No frills, nothing fancy. Just really solid, New York style Italian... food. There is also a nice group of local, regular customers. This is evidence of quality, consistency and value. I'm a fan. Read more

Cauliflower Crusted Pizza was PHENOMENAL!!! Even the kids loved it!!!! The wild mushroom slice was my go to but this blew my... mind!!! Bravo Lenny! Read more

Tonight we came across a really fine Italian restaurant and pizzeria. Ronnie our waitress was so amazing and helpful. She... took great care of us and her service was great. Tonight I had the veal cardinale was amazing. It is a break cutlet in amarsala reduction, mozzarella, prosciutto and shallots. It was so delicious and a very generous portion, served with a side ofpasta. Delicious! My wife had the chicken francaise which she enjoyed as well. Both orders were generous and served with theirfresh Italian bread. I highly recommend Lenny's. Their food is amazing, delicious and nice size! Read more

the food is good and the portions are big. they definitely need to remodel, its out dated, they have a nice bar but the waitress... is an older woman so she doesnt make modern drinks, we ended up getting wine which was pretty good; they should hire someoneyounger. the food is good though Read more

Lenny's Is the BEST...!!! I live on Shelter Island & there is no other Pizza Place & Bistro on the East End that even remotely... comes close... To the Quality, the Flavor , and the Variety of wonderful menu items...it's worth the ferry ride and a beautifulautumn drive on the North Fork...or anytime of year... ?????????????? Friendly workers & Absofreakinlutely AwesomePizza...???????????????? Read more

Pizza is great and the people are friendly. The chicken parm pizza was loaded with chicken and cheese. This is a great pizza... place thats not know by many who are just out for the vineyards so there isnt that big of a crowd. Read more