Reviews for Casey's in Jay, OK
Poorly managed. Only one gal at the register. The other waited until the line of customers was all the way back to the coolers... before she opened up the other register. I just put my stuff down and left. Read more
Order pizza the same way, and still cannot get cut right . This is on going . Need pay attention to tickets please. Other than... that workers was very friendly and helpful. Oder an other pizza 5/2/22 and still can't follow directions. Read more
Need better management. Line of customers and manager laughing with employees in the back not doing anything. Other manager is... very rude. Seems like they need alot of help there. Read more
I stopped in the store today for the first time. > have to admit I was impressed by the cleanliness of the store. I definitely... will be a repeat customer. Read more
The web site says the kitchen closes at 7 but that's false advertisement because I called at 6:26 pm & they wouldn't take my... order!! The last time I bought a Casey's pizza I was unhappy when I got home & opened the box it was thrown in the box & halfflipped over! Done with Jay Casey's won't go back even for a free pizza! Read more
Convenience store was clean and well stocked. We've stopped here for gas and snacks several times since they've opened. Friendly... and helpful staff. Read more
The pizza is excellent when I'm on a band trip I always get something quick and never regret it. The prices are a bit higher... then they should be but it is worth is especially when you get the delicious food. Salads are great, Burgers not what I wouldreally pick, slushies heck yeah I would always love a slushie, other things are still left to try and I can't wait for more butif you are on the go pick a salad it will make your day feel great but don't go heavy on dressing Read more
Prices are a bit high for a convenience store and food tastes like generic frozen foods, but overall a clean store with multiple... options. Read more