Reviews for Gaetano's Pizzeria & Creamery in Jenks, OK
Place used to be the bomb. Wouldn?t waste your time now. Didnt feel like a safe environment. Pizza was ok at best after I... watched waitress set it down on 2 other table thinking it was theirs and the Cesar salad was iceberg.. wings were decent butordered as an appetizer and got them after pizza. Read more
The ice cream was okay could have been way better if it didn't taste so frostburnt. For the amount that was paid on that ice... cream I could have just went to braum's or dairy Queen! It's not as good as everyone claimed it was going to be could have beenway better they need to learn to rotate their ice cream so it doesn't taste like the freezer! Read more
I have visited this location multiple times, but this past Saturday was superb. My husband arrived at closing time & the gent at... the counter was kind & considerate enough to fill my order for ice cream for my kids. Kudos to this young man! Read more
Ordered around 6:30 and didn't get my pizzas until 7:40. I sat in the restaurant for forty minutes waiting on two large pizzas,... a pepperoni and jalapeno and pineapple, so not a complicated order. I wasn't the only customer waiting for that time spaneither. The long wait was upsetting, but the quality has dropped as well. It's so far from how Gaetano's pizza used to be thatwe're probably not coming back. Too bad because I really liked the food before. Read more
The teens working eves, could use a stronger hand on the customer service focus, but the food is DELICIOUS!! The garlic knots... are light fluffy goodness and their pizzas are always on point with fresh ingredients and ooohhh that crust. Have only had pastathere once and that was amazing too, but due to staffing their pasta dishes are limited to early hours. Read more
I loved the pizza and the ice cream! The service was great too! We look forward to more visits.
Ate here for lunch 3 times now, small 1 topping pizza for lunch under $10, Calzone under $10 for lunch. Great pizza, great... calzone good lunch price Read more
Great local place to grab a pizza. I stopped in and got the garlic knots while waiting on my pizza to cook. A little messy but... still delicious. I started eating the pizza without thinking and didn't take a photo of it. Sorry, you get a photo of thegarlic knots instead. Read more